Apologies for the (perhaps) pedantic nature of what follows. It was the reflection I prepared for the daily mass, so it's not exactly the fun and games of my daily (mis)adventures, but hopefully it may still be worth reading.
In the series of readings from Romans that we hear this week, Paul is going on at great length about being free from the law by grace, about sin and death, and about life in the flesh vs. life in the spirit. Important themes, but confusing, and ones that we have heard, at least in caricature, so often that we can miss the depth of Paul’s understanding of our human condition. As I have written before, it isn't about seeing the body as bad and the spirit as good, but seeing the "bodily" (or better, the "fleshly") as bad -- living according to our passions. It isn't about seeing the world as bad, but about rejecting the "worldly" -- the attitudes and illusions of the mass mind. Unfortunately, our tendency is to see these texts through the mistaken lens of setting “the law,” i.e. Judaism and all the alleged nitpicky fussiness of their holiness codes, in opposition to “the gospel,” which, we say, is free from all that junk. All we need to do, so we say, is have faith, (which to our rationalistic mindset means to believe in a particular set of doctrines), and we’re good to go, we’re saved. [Note: Paul does not equate faith and belief -- faith is an existential stance, a manner of life, that generates and is generated by the ideational claims we hang on to.] Do you notice, though, that Paul talks several times about transferring our slavery from one master to another, but still being slaves? “For just as you presented the parts of your bodies as slaves to impurity and to lawlessness for lawlessness, so now present them as slaves to righteousness for sanctification.” (Rom. 6:19) “[Y]ou have been freed from sin and have become slaves of God.” (Rom. 6:22) Paul has no silly notion of freedom as being free from responsibility to other people, or just doing whatever you want, nor does he even see the law as bad. Quite the contrary: he explicitly says a few verses down the road, “So then the law is holy, and the commandment is holy and righteous and good.” (Rom. 7:12)
A few months ago I heard a speaker talk about Paul’s notion of freedom this way: who is the freest person in the world on a golf course? Or on a basketball court? Tiger Woods, maybe, on the golf course, or Michael Jordan, in his heyday, on the basketball court. It isn’t the kid who just goes and messes around, “doing whatever he wants,” but the person who submits to discipline, training, learning from the masters of the game. Michael Jordan was so free on the court because he had disciplined his body and mind to the point that he had the skills to do just about anything he wanted out there. That’s freedom. In the realm of transformation of consciousness that means freedom to do good, freedom to not be ruled by the falsehoods of popular society or of our own passions. Just like with those athletes who are free because they submit to learning from the masters of their craft, striving towards freedom means yoking ourselves to the spiritual masters – Paul, Augustine, Francis, Ignatius, Thérèse, Merton and more – and watching them in action. We read their books, not so much to multiply ideas, but to visualize them in action and to learn from them how to be. You see that in cultures in which a mentoring tradition is still alive and well, and it isn’t so much about passing on ideas, pedagogy, as it is about having people sit at the feet of the master, bringing people into the experience itself, mystagogy. Before and after the little section we read tonight, Paul talks about the members of the community being dead to sin, sharing in the death of Jesus, that “our old self was crucified with him” (Rom. 6:6) and that they are “raised from the dead to life.” (Rom. 6:13) While instruction is a part of it, and right speech does matter (I teach theology, so of course I think it’s important!), Paul emphasizes that they have been brought into the mystery, taught how to die and rise as it were, rather than that they have gotten all the doctrines formulated correctly. May we be “free to die” and allow what feels like breaking down to break us through. You know what that means -- mercy within mercy within mercy...
Friday, October 26, 2007
Tuesday, October 23, 2007
Kentucky -- Louisville and Gethsemani
Saturday night. I have just arrived at the hermitage at Bethany Spring Retreat, now owned by the Merton Institute for Contemplative Living, directed by Jonathan Montaldo, Merton expert and graduate of Cor Jesu, a Brothers’ school in New Orleans which became our present school, Brother Martin High. But I get ahead of myself…
I had to work late on Thursday, and I’ve been working fairly long hours even for me the past few weeks, so Friday I woke up kinda late. I had wanted to leave early to be sure I got to Louisville in time for the start of the conference at Bellarmine University, but I realized that I needed to do laundry, so that cost me a couple of hours. I finally left the house about 2 pm, figuring that four hours in the car would put me there around 6:00, plenty of time to find the place where I was staying, drop off my stuff, and get to Bellarmine in time for the 7:00 keynote address. Of course, it didn’t work out quite that way. Getting to Louisville was no problem, apart from having forgotten about the time zone change, and finding the place where I was staying was easy enough, but my usual skill at navigating came through again, which means that covering the 3 miles from my room to Bellarmine and finding the right building took 45 minutes. Sheesh – sometimes I think I could get lost in my own house…At least I got to see some nice parts of Louisville. Anyway, I finally found the place and heard the last half-hour or so of the talk, shook a few hands, grabbed some dinner, and went back to my room. I work nights, of course, so I couldn’t get to sleep until late, and I had to get up early (earlier because of the time change!) to be back for the start of affairs the next morning. The conference was very good, and there were a lot of folks there who are important in Merton circles: Br. Paul Quenon, OCSO; Fr. George Kilcourse; Lyn Szabo; Ron Seitz; and so on. I got to meet Tommie O’Callaghan, a tiny woman with a lot of feistiness in her eyes, who was a Louisville friend of Merton’s back in the mid-to-late 60’s. The talks were quite good, despite my lack of sleep that had me fading in and out a couple of times during the day. At lunch I went up to the Merton Center in Bellarmine’s library, saw the marvelous collections of photographs, Merton books in various and sundry languages, artwork, and a few score theses and dissertations on every conceivable aspect of Merton’s life and work. I wouldn’t mind hiding in there for a few months and reading a couple (dozen) of those…
Overall the conference was really great; one talk even gave me an idea for a paper doing an interface between Merton and Walter Brueggemann on their notions of poetry and prophecy – one of the presenters said it was a great idea and encouraged me to pursue it. When it all ended about 8:45, Br. Paul offered to let me follow him down to Gethsemani, since the place where I’m staying is only about a mile away. Tomorrow I’ll go over to the abbey to tour, go to one or two of the offices, including mass, and, thanks to Br. Paul, join a group that is going up to Merton’s hermitage! Couldn’t pass that one up…
Sunday, 21 October 2007
Morning in the hermitage was splendid; although there is heat and air conditioning, I left them off last night so I could feel the chill that lets me know that fall is finally falling. Not cold, but brisk enough to make me move through my morning ablutions with a purpose. The shower quickly ran out of hot water, reminded me of Klagetoh at Christmas, made me want to be out there again. A quick bowl of soup with a perfectly ripe avocado scooped in, a little poetry by Jalal-ud’din Rumi, and I was gone.
Sunday, 21 October 2007
Morning in the hermitage was splendid; although there is heat and air conditioning, I left them off last night so I could feel the chill that lets me know that fall is finally falling. Not cold, but brisk enough to make me move through my morning ablutions with a purpose. The shower quickly ran out of hot water, reminded me of Klagetoh at Christmas, made me want to be out there again. A quick bowl of soup with a perfectly ripe avocado scooped in, a little poetry by Jalal-ud’din Rumi, and I was gone.
I got to the monastery about 9:45, and Terce (one of the 7 daily prayer periods at the monastery) started at 10:20, so I had a little time to walk around. Nice place, nothing exceptional (which one should expect from a Trappist monastery), but I couldn’t stop wondering what exactly it looked like in Merton’s day. Even the “GOD ALONE” sign over one of the archways wasn’t the same one I had seen in older pictures of the place. I went into the abbey church a little early, looking for some quiet, but there was a group on retreat, and a lot of them were already in there, and they were a fidgety bunch, fiddling with cell phones and cameras and stage-whispering to each other about how great the quiet is. Terce finally started, a brief and slightly off-key affair, although whether that was because of the monks or the guests, I’m not sure. (*On a side note, in all the monasteries I have ever visited, they always use music that has no recognizable pattern or melody, and they go so slow as to make it almost inevitable that people will lose the beat. Doing that more than once every blue moon would drive me batty.*) After Terce, one of the monks opened a little gate that separated us from the monks’ choir stalls, and we all filed forward for Mass. The principal celebrant (the abbot, I later discovered) exuded a relaxed but no-nonsense kind of simplicity that made the liturgy very nice, all the crazy chant tones aside. Afterward, I went outside and found Br. Paul Quenon already gathering the group he had invited me to join the evening before, plus Fr. George Kilcourse assembling a group of his students from Bellarmine for a tour and picnic. I stuck with Br. Paul, who took us right away to Merton’s hermitage. It looked very much like I had expected, although not WHERE I had expected it. There were about 20 people in the group, all talking and bustling around and handling everything, so it didn’t feel quite right at first, but since I was bustling around too, taking pictures of everything, I couldn’t exactly resent them for wanting to do the same. Finally they all gathered for a lecture and I was able to find a tree trunk to curl up under and read some Edward Abbey. By this time it had become a perfect fall afternoon, ideal for doing what I was doing, and I went back and forth between reading a few pages and moving into meditation. It felt at once like I spent hours and like I was only there a few minutes, and I got an idea of why my co-worker and teacher Belden Lane writes about “backpacking with the saints” – bringing spiritual classics with him when he goes hiking or camping: reading a book by a crusty old desert rat like Ed Abbey while at the hermitage of another famous solitary somehow felt right.
After a couple of hours out there, I came back with Br. Paul to the retreat house where I was staying. The place, for a long time run by a community of sisters, was just bought by the Merton Institute for Contemplative Living and, as serendipity would have it, that was the day of the dedication ceremony, which they invited me to attend. I met the abbot, who I knew was a longtime friend of my former co-worker Judy Stewart, and Br. Patrick Hart, Merton’s secretary, as well as various and sundry board members and other Merton-philes. The ceremony was a little too long, a couple of speeches turned into verbal back-slapping of a thousand old buddies (you know the kind I mean), but all in all it was fine, and I was able to sneak away to my hermitage when the reception started.
I went back to the abbey for Vespers (evening prayer) at 5:30, then back to the retreat center for one of those wonderful, spontaneous meals in which a bunch of people show up unexpectedly, each bringing something, and strangers end up lingering at table because such a resonance occurs. The only two other people under 50 at the table were a young couple, younger than I, who are riding their bikes from Maine to Nashville, then going to a 5-week Vipassana (Buddhist) retreat. Both were very nice, so I invited them back to the hermitage after supper to see the place. We talked for a couple of hours about Merton, Buddhism, mysticism East and West, and so on. Very nice, but very telling that two former Christians went to Buddhism because they didn’t see Christianity having any kind of mystical tradition to offer. Of course it’s there, but we don’t do a good job of making it known or available – what a failure on our part to offer people more than minimalisms and legalism!
Monday, 22 October 2007
Got up early today, said my goodbyes, and got on the road. Stopped by Gethsemani again, went to the Trappists' cemetary and saw Merton's grave marker. There was still a Tibetan scarf there from when the Dalai Lama came to honor Merton. After a very minor bit of thinking, I left my cross there, the one I wear every day. I figure I'll get it back when I go next month with my students, but it seemed appropriate to offer something as important to me as that cross to the memory of a person who continues to be so important to me and to so many other people.

Sunday, October 14, 2007
birthday
So I promised a birthday post, but last week was crazy enough that it has taken me a while to get around to it. I showed up at work on Monday (my birthday) and found this poster taped to my door:
That day was a fairly normal work day; I was pretty wiped out still from the Nature Retreat, but I had meetings and stuff to be at. That evening during the community night for the Micah Program (a service-learning community with which I work) a couple of the older students came and "serenaded" me with a birthday song. Throughout the day people were coming by or leaving notes on Facebook, and a couple of people brought food, so by the end of the day my office smelled like a bakery. My friend Laura and one of the campus ministry student workers conspired to print a shirt for me (picture to follow) with "BP" on the front and "Destructo" on the back. (*Long story short -- the Brothers in my community don't change our names anymore when we take vows, but we used to up until Vatican II, and when I was a novice, I jokingly said I wanted to take the name "Destructo" as a religious name. Somehow, it followed me up here.*) I also heard from a lot of friends and Brothers throughout the day. Laura's boyfriend John found a shirt made by Schlafly's (a local brewery in StL) that had the quote, "Bier trinkt man nicht nur zum Frühstück" -- loosely translated, "Beer: it's not just for breakfast." Gee, am I that transparent?
Thursday evening I met a friend who works at a local PBS affiliate, and we watched a documentary sponsored by PBS on the Miss Navajo Nation pageant. That pageant takes place about 5 minutes from where I used to live, and it brought back a lot of memories, good and bad. Part of the pageant involves the contestants butchering a sheep -- somehow I can't picture them introducing that into the Miss America pageant...With all this monasticism stuff, and the sacred landscapes class, the desert has been calling my name for a while, so I hope to get out to AZ this winter or spring to go get lost for a while.
The parents were here this weekend, in fact just left a few hours ago, and we ran around all day yesterday. We spent most of the afternoon in the Botanical Garden -- how had I never been there before?! -- and it was just marvelous. The pond in the Japanese Garden has the biggest carp I have ever seen, and they have a little dispenser for fish food, so we fed these monsters, and they had a mini-feeding frenzy over the little pellets we were tossing them. My mom's watch dropped in the pond while she was feeding them, so we joked that some fish is going to be swimming around ticking like the crocodile in Peter Pan. I found about a hundred little hiding places I could go spend an afternoon meditating or reading. I would go next weekend, but I'll be in Kentucky at a conference on Thomas Merton's poetry, followed by a visit to Gethsemani for a couple of days. I hope I am allowed to go looking around for Merton's hermitage while I am there, but at least I can see the abbey and the cemetery. Hopefully the brunt of the cold weather stays away long enough for me to get in an afternoon or so at the Garden when I get back. I am in the planning stage of bringing the students from my class up to Gethsemani at the end of the semester to see the place, and I plan to give them a couple of hours of quiet to explore and hide and soak in the spirit of the place.
All for now. Mercy within mercy within mercy...
Monday, October 8, 2007
Nature Retreat
This weekend was the second annual SLU Nature Retreat, offered by Campus Ministry of course, at the Reis Biological Station near Steelville, MO. I worked this retreat last year, and I just couldn't wait to go on it again. I worked support staff this year and last, which basically meant cooking and cleanup, so I interacted less with the students than other staff members, but nice to not have the pressure of preparing a speech or leading a small group. My friend and co-worker Laura Buck organizes this retreat, and just does a fantastic job. Friday I got up WAY too early to go buy all the food, then loaded it all up for the folks who were going out early. The students and the rest of the staff met at 3:00 to catch a school bus out to the retreat site, but I brought a van with some more odds and ends, and I got to ride out alone, which made for a wonderful 2 hours of quiet. That night we put out hot dogs and all the fixings for everyone (see photo below), and had some introductory activities, including a marvelous reflection involving stargazing and the reading of a couple of the chapters from the end of the Book of Job, where God outlines the grandeur of creation.
Sunday was pancakes and sausage, which was lots of fun, another talk, and then mass with Fr. Joe Fortier, SJ, who did a great homily on our place in the created world, followed by lasagna for our final meal. We got out by 1:30 and home by around 4:00, by which point I was pretty wiped out, so I came home to hide for a while. All that cooking took me back to my short-order days in high school, and how much I enjoyed juggling all the different pots and pans.I know I have to put out a birthday post, so more soon...
Tuesday, October 2, 2007
goings on
Yesterday was my community's foundation day -- the 186th anniversary of our first 10 brothers taking vows at Our Lady of Fourviere church in Lyon, France. I love what I am doing here in StL, and the Marianists are marvelous, but I really missed being with my brothers for our celebration. I emailed a bunch of the bro's, and got back quite a few replies, including encouragements about the work up here and the Haiti trip. Nice reminder of our connection to each other, distance or no.
This next weekend is the SLU Nature Retreat, and I can't wait. It is only starting to get cold in the evenings (50s), whereas last year at this time it was frigid (for a Southern boy like myself). Camping, stargazing, canoeing, and more are all on the menu for the weekend, and I get to be support staff -- cooking and behind the scenes stuff. As much as I enjoy cranking out speeches and doing "spiritual direction" with people, cooking eggs and pancakes for 3 dozen people is a nice change of pace.
I got a notification on Facebook today that the sister of a student who comes rock climbing every week made the following comment on one of the photos she took of us at the climbing gym: "veronica!!! mommy says that british pertoleum looks like a thief!!!!! can u believe that. anyway he does not look like a brother (no offense to him of course he probably is super devoted and super after all that u told me but o well)"
A thief? Me? Here's the pic -- I'm the bald one. Judge for yourself...

In case you were wondering, "british pertoleum" (sic), by the way, is me -- BP for Brother Patrick.
Oh, the SLU chapter of Habitat for Humanity is trying to recruit me to be their new staff advisor, so I went back to the build site this past weekend to get to know a few more of them. Good time, not even close to the physical intensity of the week before. Which is good, because my hands were sore a whole week after the last time...
Here we are at lunch -- I promise we're not just hanging around wasting time!
Here we are at lunch -- I promise we're not just hanging around wasting time!All for now. Mercy within mercy within mercy...
Sunday, September 30, 2007
The belly of a paradox
Next Monday (October 8) I turn 30. Yeesh. Franciscan priest Richard Rohr, who writes a lot on masculine spirituality and initiation rituals, says that it's hard for us to "get it" in terms of the spiritual quest before the age of 30, so I'm really hoping that I am about to start to "get it." It also just so happens that the readings for that day are from the Book of Jonah, a delightful little book with a serious message. In the monastic literature, Jonah in the belly of the beast is a standard image for the "hidden life" of the monk in the monastery, being transformed (digested?) by the encounter with God's purposes taking him/her in a direction away from his/her desires.
Just as Thomas Merton, in his classic book The Sign of Jonas, could contrast his desire for more solitude and silence (with the Carthusians or Camaldolese hermits) with the inexplicable something that kept him at Gethsemani despite the noise, the busyness, the crowdedness, I can look back over the last eleven years as a member of the Brothers of the Sacred Heart and marvel at the inexplicable something that has conspired to overcome my impatience, my arrogance, my personal preferences. In many cultures, the initiation of the boy into the young man involves a ritual death, such as baptism in the early church, or even “digestion” by a god or a monster, which culminates in a ritual rebirth. I can’t exactly say I have had more than my share of death to deal with, but I am greatly blessed that my community has, as Richard Rohr puts it, held my feet to the fire long enough to become feet. I say all of this by way of gratitude to the community of Brothers and friends and family who have mentored me and put up with more from me than any of us realize, and by way of introduction to the little essay that follows. I wrote this for the directed readings course I am taking on "Sacred Landscapes" -- spirituality and geography -- as a synthesis of the book The Solace of Fierce Landscapes, by my teacher Belden Lane.
“[L]ike Jonas himself I find myself traveling toward my destiny in the belly of a paradox.” (Merton 11) Images of being swallowed, digested, and regurgitated abound in the mythological literature, including the Judeo-Christian scriptures, and in the monastic tradition of Christianity. What is it about the archetype of the “belly of the beast” that serves as an image of transformation in so many cultures and spiritual traditions?
Central to the desert spirituality and the transformation that takes place “in the belly of the beast” is an anthropology that understands our truest self over against the ego, which operates on a certain set of illusions and falsehoods. If it is true that the primary task of the ego is to secure itself in relation to the world, then it will follow that the ego will react negatively to anything that serves to un-secure it, whether through denial, violence, or any of a hundred other smokescreens that can distract the ego from its own essential fragility and unimportance to the world. “Now if we take our vulnerable shell to be our true identity, if we think our mask is our true face, we will protect it with fabrications even at the cost of violating our own truth.” (Cunningham 392) This seems to be why harsh taskmasters and elders have been so important in the initiation of young people in so many cultures and time periods: the ego squirms away from the “death” that initiation inevitably forces them to face. Even if it is true that “the desert tradition never seeks the destruction of the self,” (Solace 13) undercutting the ego and its need for control is a fairly standard practice, essential to bring the person into contact with the self, the true self who is to be distinguished from the false self that the ego tries to construct for itself.
Here the image of the belly of the beast becomes important. For Jonah, the beast symbolizes that which takes him in a direction he does not want to go, while “the sign of Jonas” represents for Jesus the transformation that comes from entering into death. For the Christian, as Merton puts it, “To fully ‘hear’ and ‘receive’ the word of the cross means much more than simple assent to the dogmatic proposition that Christ died for out sins. It means to be ‘nailed to the cross with Christ,’ so that the ego-self is no longer the principle of our deepest actions, which now proceed from Christ living in us.” (Cunningham 418) This rather wintry piety is essential to avoid turning Dame Julian’s deep truth, “All will be well” into an artificially sunny (and self-serving) “All will be well for me.” Like the parent who lets the baby cry itself to sleep rather than get up every time it makes a little noise, the belly of the beast is a reminder that the world is not here to be at my disposal. Job, another of the many classic Biblical figures who are thrown into the belly of the beast, has to reckon with the fact that the world “goes on perfectly well without him, even though it surely seemed in the bleak corridors of his imagination that nothing could have continued beyond the enormity of his suffering.” (Solace 55)
What happens when there is no one around to affirm all the personae I put out for people to praise or console, when no one is impressed by how many degrees or cars or sexual conquests (or, for that matter, levels of humility or spiritual “attainments”) I have racked up? In such a situation, “the fragile ego loses its props and supporting lines. Its incessant need for validation is ignored.” (Solace 43) This is quite a far cry from the “Jesus loves me, this I know” brand of Christianity which has so compartmentalized God to some private corner of my life that all it can do is bolster my self-esteem, the “housebroken and eminently companionable” God (Solace 53) who is functionally an extension of my ego and so has nothing new to challenge me with. It is also, by the way, a far cry from the God whose truth can be summed up, "Vote Republican" or "Vote Democrat," a God who is useful only for structure legitimation, which is the crudest and most shameless extension of ego legitimation.
The true solitary is able to critique and challenge, without needing to condemn (and without needing to see him- or herself as a prophet), because he or she has seen his or her own voracious ego and has been caught in the web of attachments to false security and gratification; the solitary too has known the “rhinoceritis” (in Merton’s language) within him- or herself and has felt the temptation to join the herd. It is for this reason that the desert mothers and fathers feared pride as the greatest of sins in the desert: contempt for the world could lead them to believe that they were better than others, that they were free of the ego-chains that bound “ordinary” people, in effect lording their poverty over the wealthy and taking pride in their humility. However necessary asceticism-as-discipline may be for the sake of equilibrium and attentiveness, the danger is that the person see him/herself as a hero, as having accomplished something through force of will that others have not, which is simply one more accomplishment upon which the ego could hang its hat.
Biblical language such as John’s use of “the world” or Paul’s use of “the flesh” as something in opposition to the kingdom of God has long been misunderstood, often producing a dualistic, spiritualized concept of salvation that dismisses sexuality as shameful and injustice as irrelevant to gospel. Both metaphors, however, point to something quite different: not “the world” as physical place, but rather “the worldly” as set of assumptions about who and what we truly are; not “the flesh” as weak and sinful biology, but “the fleshly” that makes either our appetites or our neuroses the standard of behavior. In contradistinction to these two stands the proper understanding of the monastic virtue of contemptus mundi: not a literal “contempt for the world,” but contempt for the illusions that the uncritical ego assumes are the final reality of the world and the self. “What they [the desert monks] fled with greatest fear was not the external world, but the world they carried inside themselves: an ego-centeredness needing constant approval, driven by compulsive behavior, frantic in its effort to attend to a self-image that always required mending.” (Solace 166)
Ideally, there is nothing left to prove, nothing left but to acknowledge one’s own falsehoods and humility; if the desert, as vast and ancient as it is, does not seem to take my ego and its demands seriously, why should I? “The greatest spiritual teachers in Zen Buddhism were those who took themselves least seriously. When they met each other, they would roll with laughter at the idea that they were supposed to be holy and worthy of reverence-having somehow mastered the infinite in their teachings. They drew pictures of each other with fat stomachs and scowling faces, dressed in tattered clothes, playing in the dirt with children. They gave titles to each other, such as ‘Great Bag of Rice’ or ‘Snowflake on a Hot Oven.’” (“Zen Clown” 260) One author, reviewing the film Into Great Silence, says of the Carthusians pictured in the film, “They look like soldiers. I suppose that means that they look like men who have seen a lot, and borne a lot. They also look like men you wouldn't cross: they look almost like criminals in that way. One might say, too, that they look like the ideal of the peasant or the seaman. Some of them permit themselves a dry, minimal smile, and those are very enigmatic moments.” (North) They don’t have angelic faces, don’t smugly look down on the lay person who comes to film them or claim to have mastered the mysteries of God. They are simply men, albeit men who have spent their lives trying to cut through the noise of “the world,” both the external world and their egos’ needs to “be somebody.”
Ritualized encounters with death in the belly of the beast typically enact rebirth as well, so that the tomb is at once the womb, from the emergence from the deathly waters in early baptism (“You have died, and your life is hidden with Christ in God” – Col 3:3) through the emergence of the initiate from the womb of the sweatlodge. The kernel of the ego, with the falsity of life it needed to live to sustain itself, has been cracked so that the new life of the true self (which was always there, but unseen and unlived) can be manifest. “Thus, in the heart of anguish [that is, the belly of the beast] are found the gifts of peace and understanding: not simply in personal illumination and liberation, but by commitment and empathy, for the comtemplative must assume the universal anguish and the inescapable condition of mortal man.” (Cunningham 394) That is, kenosis, the desert, the belly of the whale, has on the far side of it an opening up into compassion, which comes from having seen the shipwreck of one’s own inner life, having seen the foolishness of the person we try to present to others, having an ongoing awareness of one’s own dance between addiction and grace, and thus being able to recognize the same in other people.
Cunningham, Lawrence. Thomas Merton: Spiritual Master. Mahwah, NJ: Paulist Press, 1992.
Lane, Belden. “Merton as Zen Clown.” Theology Today. Vol. 46, #3, October 1989 pp 256-68.
---. The Solace of Fierce Landscapes. NY: Oxford University Press, 1998.
Merton, Thomas. The Sign of Jonas. NY: Harcourt & Brace, 1953.
North, Philip. “Being a Fly on the Monastery Enclosure Wall: Into Great Silence- Philip
Gröning.” The Social Affairs Unit. March 9, 2007.
< http://www.socialaffairsunit.org.uk/blog/archives/001436.php> Accessed 30 September 2007.
Just as Thomas Merton, in his classic book The Sign of Jonas, could contrast his desire for more solitude and silence (with the Carthusians or Camaldolese hermits) with the inexplicable something that kept him at Gethsemani despite the noise, the busyness, the crowdedness, I can look back over the last eleven years as a member of the Brothers of the Sacred Heart and marvel at the inexplicable something that has conspired to overcome my impatience, my arrogance, my personal preferences. In many cultures, the initiation of the boy into the young man involves a ritual death, such as baptism in the early church, or even “digestion” by a god or a monster, which culminates in a ritual rebirth. I can’t exactly say I have had more than my share of death to deal with, but I am greatly blessed that my community has, as Richard Rohr puts it, held my feet to the fire long enough to become feet. I say all of this by way of gratitude to the community of Brothers and friends and family who have mentored me and put up with more from me than any of us realize, and by way of introduction to the little essay that follows. I wrote this for the directed readings course I am taking on "Sacred Landscapes" -- spirituality and geography -- as a synthesis of the book The Solace of Fierce Landscapes, by my teacher Belden Lane.
“[L]ike Jonas himself I find myself traveling toward my destiny in the belly of a paradox.” (Merton 11) Images of being swallowed, digested, and regurgitated abound in the mythological literature, including the Judeo-Christian scriptures, and in the monastic tradition of Christianity. What is it about the archetype of the “belly of the beast” that serves as an image of transformation in so many cultures and spiritual traditions?
Central to the desert spirituality and the transformation that takes place “in the belly of the beast” is an anthropology that understands our truest self over against the ego, which operates on a certain set of illusions and falsehoods. If it is true that the primary task of the ego is to secure itself in relation to the world, then it will follow that the ego will react negatively to anything that serves to un-secure it, whether through denial, violence, or any of a hundred other smokescreens that can distract the ego from its own essential fragility and unimportance to the world. “Now if we take our vulnerable shell to be our true identity, if we think our mask is our true face, we will protect it with fabrications even at the cost of violating our own truth.” (Cunningham 392) This seems to be why harsh taskmasters and elders have been so important in the initiation of young people in so many cultures and time periods: the ego squirms away from the “death” that initiation inevitably forces them to face. Even if it is true that “the desert tradition never seeks the destruction of the self,” (Solace 13) undercutting the ego and its need for control is a fairly standard practice, essential to bring the person into contact with the self, the true self who is to be distinguished from the false self that the ego tries to construct for itself.
Here the image of the belly of the beast becomes important. For Jonah, the beast symbolizes that which takes him in a direction he does not want to go, while “the sign of Jonas” represents for Jesus the transformation that comes from entering into death. For the Christian, as Merton puts it, “To fully ‘hear’ and ‘receive’ the word of the cross means much more than simple assent to the dogmatic proposition that Christ died for out sins. It means to be ‘nailed to the cross with Christ,’ so that the ego-self is no longer the principle of our deepest actions, which now proceed from Christ living in us.” (Cunningham 418) This rather wintry piety is essential to avoid turning Dame Julian’s deep truth, “All will be well” into an artificially sunny (and self-serving) “All will be well for me.” Like the parent who lets the baby cry itself to sleep rather than get up every time it makes a little noise, the belly of the beast is a reminder that the world is not here to be at my disposal. Job, another of the many classic Biblical figures who are thrown into the belly of the beast, has to reckon with the fact that the world “goes on perfectly well without him, even though it surely seemed in the bleak corridors of his imagination that nothing could have continued beyond the enormity of his suffering.” (Solace 55)
What happens when there is no one around to affirm all the personae I put out for people to praise or console, when no one is impressed by how many degrees or cars or sexual conquests (or, for that matter, levels of humility or spiritual “attainments”) I have racked up? In such a situation, “the fragile ego loses its props and supporting lines. Its incessant need for validation is ignored.” (Solace 43) This is quite a far cry from the “Jesus loves me, this I know” brand of Christianity which has so compartmentalized God to some private corner of my life that all it can do is bolster my self-esteem, the “housebroken and eminently companionable” God (Solace 53) who is functionally an extension of my ego and so has nothing new to challenge me with. It is also, by the way, a far cry from the God whose truth can be summed up, "Vote Republican" or "Vote Democrat," a God who is useful only for structure legitimation, which is the crudest and most shameless extension of ego legitimation.
The true solitary is able to critique and challenge, without needing to condemn (and without needing to see him- or herself as a prophet), because he or she has seen his or her own voracious ego and has been caught in the web of attachments to false security and gratification; the solitary too has known the “rhinoceritis” (in Merton’s language) within him- or herself and has felt the temptation to join the herd. It is for this reason that the desert mothers and fathers feared pride as the greatest of sins in the desert: contempt for the world could lead them to believe that they were better than others, that they were free of the ego-chains that bound “ordinary” people, in effect lording their poverty over the wealthy and taking pride in their humility. However necessary asceticism-as-discipline may be for the sake of equilibrium and attentiveness, the danger is that the person see him/herself as a hero, as having accomplished something through force of will that others have not, which is simply one more accomplishment upon which the ego could hang its hat.
Biblical language such as John’s use of “the world” or Paul’s use of “the flesh” as something in opposition to the kingdom of God has long been misunderstood, often producing a dualistic, spiritualized concept of salvation that dismisses sexuality as shameful and injustice as irrelevant to gospel. Both metaphors, however, point to something quite different: not “the world” as physical place, but rather “the worldly” as set of assumptions about who and what we truly are; not “the flesh” as weak and sinful biology, but “the fleshly” that makes either our appetites or our neuroses the standard of behavior. In contradistinction to these two stands the proper understanding of the monastic virtue of contemptus mundi: not a literal “contempt for the world,” but contempt for the illusions that the uncritical ego assumes are the final reality of the world and the self. “What they [the desert monks] fled with greatest fear was not the external world, but the world they carried inside themselves: an ego-centeredness needing constant approval, driven by compulsive behavior, frantic in its effort to attend to a self-image that always required mending.” (Solace 166)
Ideally, there is nothing left to prove, nothing left but to acknowledge one’s own falsehoods and humility; if the desert, as vast and ancient as it is, does not seem to take my ego and its demands seriously, why should I? “The greatest spiritual teachers in Zen Buddhism were those who took themselves least seriously. When they met each other, they would roll with laughter at the idea that they were supposed to be holy and worthy of reverence-having somehow mastered the infinite in their teachings. They drew pictures of each other with fat stomachs and scowling faces, dressed in tattered clothes, playing in the dirt with children. They gave titles to each other, such as ‘Great Bag of Rice’ or ‘Snowflake on a Hot Oven.’” (“Zen Clown” 260) One author, reviewing the film Into Great Silence, says of the Carthusians pictured in the film, “They look like soldiers. I suppose that means that they look like men who have seen a lot, and borne a lot. They also look like men you wouldn't cross: they look almost like criminals in that way. One might say, too, that they look like the ideal of the peasant or the seaman. Some of them permit themselves a dry, minimal smile, and those are very enigmatic moments.” (North) They don’t have angelic faces, don’t smugly look down on the lay person who comes to film them or claim to have mastered the mysteries of God. They are simply men, albeit men who have spent their lives trying to cut through the noise of “the world,” both the external world and their egos’ needs to “be somebody.”
Ritualized encounters with death in the belly of the beast typically enact rebirth as well, so that the tomb is at once the womb, from the emergence from the deathly waters in early baptism (“You have died, and your life is hidden with Christ in God” – Col 3:3) through the emergence of the initiate from the womb of the sweatlodge. The kernel of the ego, with the falsity of life it needed to live to sustain itself, has been cracked so that the new life of the true self (which was always there, but unseen and unlived) can be manifest. “Thus, in the heart of anguish [that is, the belly of the beast] are found the gifts of peace and understanding: not simply in personal illumination and liberation, but by commitment and empathy, for the comtemplative must assume the universal anguish and the inescapable condition of mortal man.” (Cunningham 394) That is, kenosis, the desert, the belly of the whale, has on the far side of it an opening up into compassion, which comes from having seen the shipwreck of one’s own inner life, having seen the foolishness of the person we try to present to others, having an ongoing awareness of one’s own dance between addiction and grace, and thus being able to recognize the same in other people.
Cunningham, Lawrence. Thomas Merton: Spiritual Master. Mahwah, NJ: Paulist Press, 1992.
Lane, Belden. “Merton as Zen Clown.” Theology Today. Vol. 46, #3, October 1989 pp 256-68.
---. The Solace of Fierce Landscapes. NY: Oxford University Press, 1998.
Merton, Thomas. The Sign of Jonas. NY: Harcourt & Brace, 1953.
North, Philip. “Being a Fly on the Monastery Enclosure Wall: Into Great Silence- Philip
Gröning.” The Social Affairs Unit. March 9, 2007.
< http://www.socialaffairsunit.org.uk/blog/archives/001436.php> Accessed 30 September 2007.
Monday, September 24, 2007
23 September 2007
This weekend was the Marianists’ province chapter in Dayton, so one of the Brothers in another local community in the area asked me to house-sit, since all the Brothers in that house would be out of town. I wish I could say that I made a mini-retreat out of it and immersed myself in solitude for three days, but that would be a lie. Friday night a friend and I watched Pan’s Labyrinth on DVD – if you haven’t seen it, I highly recommend it. It’s a sort of mélange of real world and fantasy world, set against the backdrop of the Spanish Civil War, and its use of classic themes from various myths and legends from all over the world is rich and polyvalent. It’s a dark film, and very violent at times, but beautifully done.
Saturday I got up early to work with Habitat for Humanity in a somewhat rougher part of the city called the Mark Twain neighborhood. I have loved Habitat ever since my days at Catholic High, and this was a particularly great day to be on the job. First, it was a great day to be outside – mid-80s, not a cloud in the sky. Second, a bunch of students from the SLU Habitat group happened to be working on my build site, so I got to meet some of them. Third, and most important, there was a lot of stuff to hit and dig. We were mostly working landscaping all day, and when the site manager told us that, I was a little disappointed because I figured I’d be planting flowers and that kind of thing. Not so much. I ended up spending about 6 hours digging holes for trees with a post hole digger, breaking up old bricks and concrete with a pickaxe, and moving wheelbarrows full of rocks. As you might expect, I was pretty beat up by the end of it all. It is a blessing to be able to go and hit stuff and dig holes and be engaged in physical labor for a while, but it always reminds me of how grateful I am for higher education. Still, it was a great day.
After all the fun and games, I went home and collapsed for a couple of hours, but my friend Laura had her two sisters in town, so they all wanted to go out to City Museum. Of course, I’m an idiot, so I couldn’t pass up City Museum, so we went and ran around and climbed stuff for another two hours or so. When I finally crawled home after all this abuse, I felt like I had been on the receiving end of the aforementioned pickaxe, but it was completely worth it. 

After I woke up this morning and tried to stop the shaking in my hands long enough to get a few spoonfuls of cereal from the bowl to my mouth without spilling milk all over the table, I finally did enjoy having the house all to myself, so I was able to read for 4 or 5 hours before coming home and doing some work around the house and limping off to the 10pm mass.
One sadder note: since my last email, I received word that Br. Hubert Bonnette died. Br. Hubert returned to the Brothers just a few years ago after having been out of the community for several decades, and while we were only in the community together for a few years, and I didn’t get much of a chance to know him well, I knew from the first time I met him that he was the real deal: wise, humble, a real Brother’s Brother. He had that same kind of simple, honest centeredness that I saw in someone like Br. Pierre, another old hero of mine, and that has drawn me to the Brothers from my earliest days in the community. I wish I had gotten to know him better, but I am so glad for the time I was able to spend getting to know him, and that he was able to spend his last years back with his Brothers.
One sadder note: since my last email, I received word that Br. Hubert Bonnette died. Br. Hubert returned to the Brothers just a few years ago after having been out of the community for several decades, and while we were only in the community together for a few years, and I didn’t get much of a chance to know him well, I knew from the first time I met him that he was the real deal: wise, humble, a real Brother’s Brother. He had that same kind of simple, honest centeredness that I saw in someone like Br. Pierre, another old hero of mine, and that has drawn me to the Brothers from my earliest days in the community. I wish I had gotten to know him better, but I am so glad for the time I was able to spend getting to know him, and that he was able to spend his last years back with his Brothers.
Thursday, September 20, 2007
Reflection for 20 September
This entire week in the daily readings we have seen the contrast between hardness of heart and conversion of heart. On Sunday, the people of Israel, newly freed from Egypt, are called “stiff-necked,” while Paul describes himself as “a blasphemer and a persecutor and arrogant,” and the Pharisees are amazed that Jesus would welcome sinners and eat with them. Later we see statements about what kind of person should be chosen to be bishops and deacons, and Jesus complaining that the same people who complain about John the Baptist’s asceticism complain about Jesus’ lack of asceticism. Tomorrow will culminate with the Pharisees asking the disciples why Jesus eats with sinners, to which Jesus gives the classic answer:
“Those who are well do not need a physician, but the sick do. Go and learn the meaning of the words, I desire mercy, not sacrifice. I did not come to call the righteous but sinners.” (MT 9:12-13)
Throughout, Jesus and Paul point us toward authentic humility. Holiness is not really about all the virtuous deeds we can stack up, since that can very easily end up simply inflating our Christian egos. Jesus’ citation here of the book of Hosea (“I desire mercy, not sacrifice” – Hosea 6:6) points to a standard thread in the prophetic tradition that sacrifice without transformed consciousness, without justice and mercy, is worse than worthless, because it can so easily allow us to believe that we are “doing it right,” that all I need to do is throw a little food through the bars of the cage that I keep God in, and I will stay firmly in control of my own salvation. There is a book in which one of the characters has a vision of the afterlife, which involves crossing a bridge over a lake of fire, and the character is horrified to see that as people cross the bridge into salvation, even their virtues are being burned away. What is left for the person's ego to hang its hat on? Instead, perhaps real holiness is more about allowing ourselves to be honest and acknowledge how much of a mess we really are. Of course, we don’t want to be a mess, and we don’t even want to admit that we are a mess. But when Jesus says, “I did not come to call the righteous but sinners,” who of us can honestly say that we are righteous? Of course, the standard line in our day is to talk about how “I’m not really into religion, but I’m a good person.” What exactly does that mean? I am only too aware that I’m not a good person – in fact, the more I pay attention to what I do, and why I do it, even the stuff that on the surface looks like “good-deed-doing” usually comes out of a selfish motive – to look good, to manipulate the other person, or even just to allow myself to believe that I am a “good person.”
Do we notice how Jesus keeps going to sinners and tax collectors, to people who have been kicked around and who, we might think, deserve what they get? Do any of us really think we deserve what we get? The “sinner and tax collector” type in our time could be the compulsive gambler who loses his house and whose family leaves him, the pregnant teenager who has to face the rejection of her peers and who has to grow up really fast to raise her child, or perhaps even the politician or celebrity who gets caught in some compromising situation and gets lambasted by the media. At that point, for that person, mercy is no longer about earning Brownie points, no longer about stacking up proofs of one’s virtuousness, but about gratitude for being shown mercy. That is just what we see in today’s gospel (LK 7:36-50) – this woman who comes to Jesus has nothing to prove, no ego to wave in anybody’s face – everyone knows who she is. But Jesus never attacks what in Jungian terms we might call the shadow – what we try to keep others from seeing about ourselves – instead, he hammers the ego, in this case, Simon the Pharisee’s ability to say that this woman is not worthy of Jesus’ attention, while he (Simon) presumably is. Since he does not see himself as in need of mercy, he is not grateful for the mercy that he has in fact received and does not respond with the mercy that comes from being treated mercifully. The point of all of this is simply Jesus’ own point – what God desires from us is mercy, not a self-serving, condescending pity that can make us feel smug about how tolerant and generous we are, but the mercy that comes from realizing how desperately inadequate we are, and how desperately we are in need of the mercy we have in fact received. As usual, "Mercy within mercy within mercy..."
“Those who are well do not need a physician, but the sick do. Go and learn the meaning of the words, I desire mercy, not sacrifice. I did not come to call the righteous but sinners.” (MT 9:12-13)
Throughout, Jesus and Paul point us toward authentic humility. Holiness is not really about all the virtuous deeds we can stack up, since that can very easily end up simply inflating our Christian egos. Jesus’ citation here of the book of Hosea (“I desire mercy, not sacrifice” – Hosea 6:6) points to a standard thread in the prophetic tradition that sacrifice without transformed consciousness, without justice and mercy, is worse than worthless, because it can so easily allow us to believe that we are “doing it right,” that all I need to do is throw a little food through the bars of the cage that I keep God in, and I will stay firmly in control of my own salvation. There is a book in which one of the characters has a vision of the afterlife, which involves crossing a bridge over a lake of fire, and the character is horrified to see that as people cross the bridge into salvation, even their virtues are being burned away. What is left for the person's ego to hang its hat on? Instead, perhaps real holiness is more about allowing ourselves to be honest and acknowledge how much of a mess we really are. Of course, we don’t want to be a mess, and we don’t even want to admit that we are a mess. But when Jesus says, “I did not come to call the righteous but sinners,” who of us can honestly say that we are righteous? Of course, the standard line in our day is to talk about how “I’m not really into religion, but I’m a good person.” What exactly does that mean? I am only too aware that I’m not a good person – in fact, the more I pay attention to what I do, and why I do it, even the stuff that on the surface looks like “good-deed-doing” usually comes out of a selfish motive – to look good, to manipulate the other person, or even just to allow myself to believe that I am a “good person.”
Do we notice how Jesus keeps going to sinners and tax collectors, to people who have been kicked around and who, we might think, deserve what they get? Do any of us really think we deserve what we get? The “sinner and tax collector” type in our time could be the compulsive gambler who loses his house and whose family leaves him, the pregnant teenager who has to face the rejection of her peers and who has to grow up really fast to raise her child, or perhaps even the politician or celebrity who gets caught in some compromising situation and gets lambasted by the media. At that point, for that person, mercy is no longer about earning Brownie points, no longer about stacking up proofs of one’s virtuousness, but about gratitude for being shown mercy. That is just what we see in today’s gospel (LK 7:36-50) – this woman who comes to Jesus has nothing to prove, no ego to wave in anybody’s face – everyone knows who she is. But Jesus never attacks what in Jungian terms we might call the shadow – what we try to keep others from seeing about ourselves – instead, he hammers the ego, in this case, Simon the Pharisee’s ability to say that this woman is not worthy of Jesus’ attention, while he (Simon) presumably is. Since he does not see himself as in need of mercy, he is not grateful for the mercy that he has in fact received and does not respond with the mercy that comes from being treated mercifully. The point of all of this is simply Jesus’ own point – what God desires from us is mercy, not a self-serving, condescending pity that can make us feel smug about how tolerant and generous we are, but the mercy that comes from realizing how desperately inadequate we are, and how desperately we are in need of the mercy we have in fact received. As usual, "Mercy within mercy within mercy..."
Friday, September 7, 2007
reflection for 6 September -- a fish story
Today’s gospel (LK 5:1-11) is one of those fish stories that you might expect an uncle or a grandpa to tell. Interesting that not only does Peter catch a lot of fish, not only is he assigned to start catching people, but I presume it isn’t lost on him that he himself has been hooked and reeled in by Jesus.
This gospel story of Peter’s interaction with Jesus after a miraculous catch of fish looks like it parallels the story at the end of John’s gospel, but it is interesting to see how Peter interacts with Jesus in each. Here in Luke, upon making such a large catch, Peter wants Jesus to leave him for, as he puts it, “he is a sinful man.” In John, upon seeing the catch of fish, Peter, who has just denied Jesus a couple of days before, jumps in the water and goes racing toward him, although he is quite obviously still a sinful man! What is going on here? Peter knows that this catch of fish is not simply Jesus’ way of paying for letting him sit in his boat while he teaches the crowds, not simply a “thanks for all the fish, Jesus” kind of thing. If this were just about getting a great catch of fish where previously he had none, he would tell Jesus to stick around and have the revenue keep pouring in, but instead he begs Jesus to leave him alone. Why? Presumably because he knows what’s coming, which is a call to follow in some dangerous footsteps, and which is not where he wants to go. Perhaps I am going way out on an exegetical limb here, but perhaps these fish do something like what the owls do at the beginning of the Harry Potter series, or the white rabbit does in Alice in Wonderland: they call Peter into a new realm that takes him away from the security and stability of home. There is something really scary here, because all of the efforts to manage one’s own life get shot to pieces, and being thrown into this kind of unknown means that there is nothing tangible to count on. Rather like another famous fish story, that of Jonah in the belly of the beast, this kind of encounter takes your ego in a direction it doesn’t want to go. We want to be at the helm, but the reality of life is that we aren’t, and despite all our attempts to manage our reality, God calls us to something beyond the control and techniques of our voracious egos. Joseph Campbell puts it this way in his study of heroic figures in myth and literature: “The divinity itself became his terror; for, obviously, if one is oneself one’s god, then God himself, the will of God, the power that would destroy one’s egocentric system, becomes a monster.” (Campbell 60) This is just what Jesus points to in the parallel fish story, when he tells Peter, “‘when you were younger, you used to dress yourself and go where you wanted; but when you grow old, you will stretch out your hands, and someone else will dress you and lead you where you do not want to go.’ He said this signifying by what kind of death he would glorify God.” If Peter would have known about all that at that first fishy encounter, perhaps he would have been less likely to bite the hook that Jesus threw out for him.
Let me try to draw this fish story together with the photograph on the left side of this blog. This was taken by Thomas Merton in the late 60s. He jokingly titled it, “The only known photograph of God.” The image, playful but serious, is that God is always throwing us a line, hoping we’ll bite, whether through our classes or family or through communities of faith like this one. Such morsels of bait often contain within them a sharp edge, usually involving being drawn out of our little fishbowl into new and scary situations of undercutting the image of ourselves that we want to project and believe in. The call is to become more concerned with prophecy than survival, more about following the path of the cross than the path of my secure plan for myself, to become more deeply conformed to Christ, emptied of self, clarified into men and women of peace and compassion.
This gospel story of Peter’s interaction with Jesus after a miraculous catch of fish looks like it parallels the story at the end of John’s gospel, but it is interesting to see how Peter interacts with Jesus in each. Here in Luke, upon making such a large catch, Peter wants Jesus to leave him for, as he puts it, “he is a sinful man.” In John, upon seeing the catch of fish, Peter, who has just denied Jesus a couple of days before, jumps in the water and goes racing toward him, although he is quite obviously still a sinful man! What is going on here? Peter knows that this catch of fish is not simply Jesus’ way of paying for letting him sit in his boat while he teaches the crowds, not simply a “thanks for all the fish, Jesus” kind of thing. If this were just about getting a great catch of fish where previously he had none, he would tell Jesus to stick around and have the revenue keep pouring in, but instead he begs Jesus to leave him alone. Why? Presumably because he knows what’s coming, which is a call to follow in some dangerous footsteps, and which is not where he wants to go. Perhaps I am going way out on an exegetical limb here, but perhaps these fish do something like what the owls do at the beginning of the Harry Potter series, or the white rabbit does in Alice in Wonderland: they call Peter into a new realm that takes him away from the security and stability of home. There is something really scary here, because all of the efforts to manage one’s own life get shot to pieces, and being thrown into this kind of unknown means that there is nothing tangible to count on. Rather like another famous fish story, that of Jonah in the belly of the beast, this kind of encounter takes your ego in a direction it doesn’t want to go. We want to be at the helm, but the reality of life is that we aren’t, and despite all our attempts to manage our reality, God calls us to something beyond the control and techniques of our voracious egos. Joseph Campbell puts it this way in his study of heroic figures in myth and literature: “The divinity itself became his terror; for, obviously, if one is oneself one’s god, then God himself, the will of God, the power that would destroy one’s egocentric system, becomes a monster.” (Campbell 60) This is just what Jesus points to in the parallel fish story, when he tells Peter, “‘when you were younger, you used to dress yourself and go where you wanted; but when you grow old, you will stretch out your hands, and someone else will dress you and lead you where you do not want to go.’ He said this signifying by what kind of death he would glorify God.” If Peter would have known about all that at that first fishy encounter, perhaps he would have been less likely to bite the hook that Jesus threw out for him.
Let me try to draw this fish story together with the photograph on the left side of this blog. This was taken by Thomas Merton in the late 60s. He jokingly titled it, “The only known photograph of God.” The image, playful but serious, is that God is always throwing us a line, hoping we’ll bite, whether through our classes or family or through communities of faith like this one. Such morsels of bait often contain within them a sharp edge, usually involving being drawn out of our little fishbowl into new and scary situations of undercutting the image of ourselves that we want to project and believe in. The call is to become more concerned with prophecy than survival, more about following the path of the cross than the path of my secure plan for myself, to become more deeply conformed to Christ, emptied of self, clarified into men and women of peace and compassion.
Tuesday, September 4, 2007
hoo boy
I just finished my class a few moments ago, and I am just blown away at what is going on in there. We started talking about the desert tradition, and I figured I would spend 20 minutes or so lecturing, we'd do some discussion, and then I'd move on with the cenobites. Geez, we ended up talking about the desert stuff the whole time, and still have more to cover! We got into some heavy stuff like kataphatic and apophatic prayer and theology, which I had intended to hold off until later, but it came about of itself, so we had to open that can of worms. I am enjoying it so much, it's actually making me nervous. I pray the students are enjoying it all, but I fear that I am talking too much, being too oblique, too vague. They are asking amazing questions, but it's obvious that they aren't just rehashing stuff they already know. They knew the basics of the legalization of Christianity, for example, but when we got into the apophatic stuff and quies and the Jesus prayer, they didn't seem to know it, but they jumped all over it. The hunger out there for something people can sink their teeth into is just mind-boggling. It's so hard to talk about any of that stuff, and the whole time we are talking our words are just failing miserably, and we're all laughing at our poor efforts to express intelligently what we know we want to say, but I can tell that people are really getting fired up about it. Everything they say sets off ten ideas in my mind, so I really hope I'm not so scattered that I am just muddling the confusion even more. I wish we could just sit together in silence for a few hours and let the silence do the talking, but we are condemned to speak. O God, let my words and the clutter of my thoughts not be a hindrance to the utter simplicity and silence that You are. Mercy within mercy within mercy...
friends
So this evening a few old and new friends from the local Catholic Worker house came over to my place for a while, and it was so nice to be able to reconnect, talk with like-minded people of similar age, and listen to how they are putting their energies into really trying to be men and women of peace and simplicity and of protest against a popular culture that seems to be constantly on the verge of implosion under the weight of its collective ego. Each person in the conversation has stories of spending weeks or months or years in Central America or Africa, working in another language, and working with some very marginal people. On that last note, I again find myself restless at the thought of the kind of life they and I lead. Hopefully this doesn't have roots in the old ego-serving concepts like how difficult the work is, so that I could feel more heroic if I worked in more trying circumstances, but given the immensity of immediate needs around the world, for food, vaccinations, basic literacy, and so on, it makes me aware what a luxury it is to have the time and means to do theology, to offer ministerial services to students, to have all the resources I have at my fingertips. My Catholic Worker friends generally do very earthy but very important works: maintenance work at a nursing home, teaching at an alternative high school, advocacy with a local community organization, running a food line for hungry people, letting homeless people crash on their couches. Perhaps part of me envies that kind of earthiness, but on the other hand, I have to acknowledge that I have some measure of aptitude for doing theological work, and that I am retreating into solitude more and more frequently as I get older. I wouldn't really want to go home to the noise and controlled chaos that is the usual Catholic Worker house, nor do I think I would best make use of my abilities by spending my days directing janitorial staff or piddling through algebra I (but I have done so before, and kudos to those who do it). I have no notions that I am accomplishing something magical by spending a lot of time in silence, and I can't even claim that I am developing some kind of spiritual depth that my friends aren't getting because they are too "active." On the contrary -- I feel less and less like I have made any kind of "progress" (whatever that means) in the religious life, institutionally speaking, or in the spiritual life, existentially speaking. My every action still seems to proceed from amazingly selfish motives, or better yet, from an addiction to the cult of ME. Even tonight, I am ashamed at how much I tried to "compete" (unsuccessfully) with the experiences the others have had, how hard I tried to sound wise or to sound theologically sophisticated or to turn the conversation back to myself. There is the true monastic ideal of "contemptus mundi" -- contempt for the world -- not hating secular things or living in some rarefied (and false) holiness, but freeing oneself from attachment to the images of success that are held up for us: degrees earned, countries visited, languages mastered, and so on. What will it take to crack through the seemingly endless layers of self-defense mechanisms that just can't stand the fact that I am not the smartest or wisest or most talented guy in the room?
Tuesday, August 28, 2007
When the Moon says Nothing
Yesterday the newspaper had a blurb about the full lunar eclipse that was going on this morning, and I can't remember ever seeing one before, so despite reading Merton until the wee hours, I set my alarm for 4:30 so I could watch it. I woke up and looked out my window; I could just barely get the right angle to see the moon, and by that time it was about halfway into the eclipse. There was a rather ghostly sort of halo around it, but by the time I drove out to Forest Park to have a clearer line of sight, it was nearly fully eclipsed, and the halo was gone. Nevertheless, it was still a marvelous sight, elegant in its simplicity, and I sat for about half an hour and just watched it. As the saying goes, "When the wise man points at the moon, all the idiot sees is the finger." It made me realize, though, that the final eclipsed state of affairs, while beautiful, wasn't anything flashy or 180 degrees away from the norm, like a solar eclipse or something -- the normal moon is just as spellbinding, so why don't I ever go out to watch it during its normal wax and wane...?
This afternoon was the first meeting of my class on Thomas Merton, and of course I was on high alert all day, reading as much as I could cram into the afternoon, as if those few pages would save me from what would otherwise be a disaster. Fr. Hellmann (the department chair) told me yesterday that he would love if this class could become a regular feature, and of course I thought, "YOU'D love it?!?" It's just silly how many people have done so much to enable me to do all this, from being a Brother of the Sacred Heart in the first place, to being at SLU, to being allowed to teach this class. Seven people actually showed up today, which is fine, but I am learning to assume nothing about final numbers -- it could go up or down for some time now. As circumstances had it, I opened a book of Merton's nature writings (called When the Trees Say Nothing), just at random, and I found a little thing on a lunar eclipse he observed, presumably from his hermitage. Since I have been planning to read a prayer or poem or journal entry by Merton before every class anyway, I figured this one would do. I quote it here in part: "The moon was beautiful, dimly red, like a globe of almost transparent amber...It hung there between two tall pines, silent, unexplained, small, with a modest suggestion of bloodiness, an omen without fierceness and without comment, pure." Oh God, let my words this semester be heavy with the silence that makes that kind of reality present! Mercy within mercy within mercy...
This afternoon was the first meeting of my class on Thomas Merton, and of course I was on high alert all day, reading as much as I could cram into the afternoon, as if those few pages would save me from what would otherwise be a disaster. Fr. Hellmann (the department chair) told me yesterday that he would love if this class could become a regular feature, and of course I thought, "YOU'D love it?!?" It's just silly how many people have done so much to enable me to do all this, from being a Brother of the Sacred Heart in the first place, to being at SLU, to being allowed to teach this class. Seven people actually showed up today, which is fine, but I am learning to assume nothing about final numbers -- it could go up or down for some time now. As circumstances had it, I opened a book of Merton's nature writings (called When the Trees Say Nothing), just at random, and I found a little thing on a lunar eclipse he observed, presumably from his hermitage. Since I have been planning to read a prayer or poem or journal entry by Merton before every class anyway, I figured this one would do. I quote it here in part: "The moon was beautiful, dimly red, like a globe of almost transparent amber...It hung there between two tall pines, silent, unexplained, small, with a modest suggestion of bloodiness, an omen without fierceness and without comment, pure." Oh God, let my words this semester be heavy with the silence that makes that kind of reality present! Mercy within mercy within mercy...
Tuesday, August 21, 2007
Tuesday, 21 August
The first reading for today’s liturgy (Judges 6:11-24a), about Gideon being commissioned by the angel of the Lord to destroy the Midianites, is one of those texts that doesn’t sit well with our modern sensibilities because of the violence it has God demanding, but it is also a powerful and important text. The background of the story is that Israel is under the rule of the Midianites, and Gideon is using the wine press to thresh his wheat, so the Midianites don’t see it and force him to give it to them as tribute. The angel of the Lord shows up and hails Gideon in language reminiscent of that used with Mary in LK 1: “The Lord is with you, O champion!” Gideon doesn’t bite the hook, though, saying, “My Lord, if the LORD is with us, why has all this happened to us? Where are his wondrous deeds of which our fathers told us when they said, ‘Did not the LORD bring us up from Egypt?’ For now the LORD has abandoned us and has delivered us into the power of Midian.” This is Jewish theodicy at its best, and something that Christianity has largely lost. The Christian “tri-omni” God-image (omniscient, omnipresent, and omnipotent) tends to make God seem unchanging, which doesn’t leave us with much room to be angry with God, to vent our anger and grief, since God can’t be to blame. The Old Testament tradition, though, denies neither the reality of God nor the reality of their sufferings. This God is wild, unpredictable, changeable, and may well need to be called back to keeping God’s promises, as Jeremiah (“You have duped me, O Lord, and I have allowed myself to be duped”) and the lament psalms (“How long, O Lord?”), among other texts, so well point out.
The angel’s only response is to tell Gideon to do something about it – “Go with the strength you have and save Israel from the power of Midian.” Whereas the angel addresses Gideon as “champion,” however, Gideon turns the image around and asks how this can be (again reminiscent of Mary’s interaction with the angel in LK 1) since his family is “the lowliest in Manasseh,” (itself a half-tribe) and he is “the most insignificant” in his father’s house. If he had read his Old Testament, he would know that this is how God works – always choosing the underdog: the barren woman, the enslaved nation, the younger son. David would be chosen the same way: the youngest son in a family from the tiny tribe of Benjamin.
What happens next is interesting, if confusing: As a sign, the angel has Gideon prepare an offering of unleavened bread and a kid goat, and the angel accepts it, burning up the offering and then disappearing. Gideon apparently only now realizes that he had been speaking with the angel of the Lord, and is terrified that he would die for having seen such a being face-to-face (as was the common belief in that time – see EX 33:23), only to be told, “Be calm, (literally, “Shalom,”) do not fear,” again, just as in Mary’s encounter with the angel. Memory is important for hope, because it roots hope in God’s saving actions in the past – who God is for these people is disclosed by what God does, and what God does is save, usually via the underdog.
On a side note, it is noteworthy how much of this follows Joseph Campbell’s “monomyth” – his term for the standard thread of themes that appear across cultures and eras in stories of heroes, shamans and prophets, as laid out in his classic work The Hero With a Thousand Faces. Campbell’s “normal world” here is Gideon as a nobody in the middle of nowhere, working on the family farm in a quiet, if unsatisfying, situation. Think Luke Skywalker dreaming about adventure and fighting the Empire while being stuck living on his aunt and uncle’s farm on a planet in the middle of nowhere. When the “call to adventure” (as Campbell calls it) comes, whether as “Go with the strength you have and save Israel from the power of Midian” or “You must come with me to Alderaan,” neither young hero is ready to step up, despite all the brave talk; Gideon responds with, “Please, my lord, how can I save Israel?” while Luke’s version is, “I can’t go to Alderaan – I have work to do.” This motif, which Campbell calls the “refusal of the call,” is the same kind of thing we see with Moses (the burning bush and Moses’ objection that he doesn’t speak well) and Jeremiah (the word of the Lord coming to him, and his response that he is too young), among numerous others in and out of the Bible. The hero isn’t let off the hook so easily, though, and is convinced (or, more likely, forced) to fulfill the role chosen for him.
The angel’s only response is to tell Gideon to do something about it – “Go with the strength you have and save Israel from the power of Midian.” Whereas the angel addresses Gideon as “champion,” however, Gideon turns the image around and asks how this can be (again reminiscent of Mary’s interaction with the angel in LK 1) since his family is “the lowliest in Manasseh,” (itself a half-tribe) and he is “the most insignificant” in his father’s house. If he had read his Old Testament, he would know that this is how God works – always choosing the underdog: the barren woman, the enslaved nation, the younger son. David would be chosen the same way: the youngest son in a family from the tiny tribe of Benjamin.
What happens next is interesting, if confusing: As a sign, the angel has Gideon prepare an offering of unleavened bread and a kid goat, and the angel accepts it, burning up the offering and then disappearing. Gideon apparently only now realizes that he had been speaking with the angel of the Lord, and is terrified that he would die for having seen such a being face-to-face (as was the common belief in that time – see EX 33:23), only to be told, “Be calm, (literally, “Shalom,”) do not fear,” again, just as in Mary’s encounter with the angel. Memory is important for hope, because it roots hope in God’s saving actions in the past – who God is for these people is disclosed by what God does, and what God does is save, usually via the underdog.
On a side note, it is noteworthy how much of this follows Joseph Campbell’s “monomyth” – his term for the standard thread of themes that appear across cultures and eras in stories of heroes, shamans and prophets, as laid out in his classic work The Hero With a Thousand Faces. Campbell’s “normal world” here is Gideon as a nobody in the middle of nowhere, working on the family farm in a quiet, if unsatisfying, situation. Think Luke Skywalker dreaming about adventure and fighting the Empire while being stuck living on his aunt and uncle’s farm on a planet in the middle of nowhere. When the “call to adventure” (as Campbell calls it) comes, whether as “Go with the strength you have and save Israel from the power of Midian” or “You must come with me to Alderaan,” neither young hero is ready to step up, despite all the brave talk; Gideon responds with, “Please, my lord, how can I save Israel?” while Luke’s version is, “I can’t go to Alderaan – I have work to do.” This motif, which Campbell calls the “refusal of the call,” is the same kind of thing we see with Moses (the burning bush and Moses’ objection that he doesn’t speak well) and Jeremiah (the word of the Lord coming to him, and his response that he is too young), among numerous others in and out of the Bible. The hero isn’t let off the hook so easily, though, and is convinced (or, more likely, forced) to fulfill the role chosen for him.
Sunday, August 5, 2007
comps papers
OK, since y'all have put up with me posting all kinds of other random stuff, I figure I'll go ahead and post the papers I wrote last month for my comprehensive exams for the master's degree in theology. It's not my best work, but I thought the profs came up with some good questions. Feel free to read on if you are having trouble falling asleep.
1. Summarize Roger Haight’s Spirit Christology in regard to the way it articulates the relationship of Jesus to the world religions. What do you perceive to be the value of Haight’s distinctive approach, but what also do you perceive to be its challenges and limitations?
Haight’s genetic approach to Christology attempts to understand the foundational experiences that undergirded the development of the New Testament and the later Christological formulations of the early councils. Against trying to harmonize all of the different models of Christology in the New Testament or to favor one as the premier model, as he would say has been done with the Logos model for centuries, he prefers to see all of them as metaphorical and poetic statements which point to the reality that people encounter God and God’s salvation in Jesus. Other theologians prefer to see the claim that Jesus is unique Son of God at the center of the New Testament, but for Haight, this both focuses too much on Jesus, who did not focus on himself but on God, and it neglects the reality that people ask the Christological questions because of the soteriological experience. Haight’s preferred model for this is of God as Spirit, which he sees as poetic language for God as God is present in the world, rather than as strictly hypostatic language. The benefit here is that Haight does not dismiss Logos language, but places it in dialogue with other Christologies. This opens the door for other manifestations of the Spirit to the world, but it is hard to qualify “degrees” of the presence of the Spirit, so it is unclear what makes Jesus different from the prophet Jeremiah or Archbishop Oscar Romero.
Haight has at the center of his method two basic claims: God desires the salvation of all, and there is no unmediated experience of God. This means that Haight has a hard time with the “scandal of particularity” in the sense of seeing God as particularly privileging one group or religion or moment in history. In looking at the world religions, Haight says that it is to be expected that there would be many, and widely different, ways of speaking about the revelation of the divine, precisely because the experience of God comes precisely through the mediation of the cultures of the world, which obviously are extremely diverse. One significant issue here is that numerous religions do not seem to be reaching out for a salvation that is in any serious way like what Christians claim. Haight attempts to deal with this by saying that the true centerpiece of religion is the experience of negativity: meaninglessness in human history, finitude, suffering, death, and massive social evil. The concern for salvation which Haight says drives all religious thought is in fact not necessarily a concern for afterlife or divine deliverance but a concern for the experience of negativity. Just as Jesus is important because people experience in him the presence of God and a response to the problem of negativity, so for the other religions in their own distinct ways.
In keeping with Haight’s desire to respond to such negativity, he warns that any model of salvation must deal with earthly reality, or in his terms, liberation. He particularly addresses the modern Western notion of an individualistic salvation, which to his mind enables refusal to address the reality of the suffering in the world and as such proves correct the analysis of figures like Marx who see religion blinding or numbing people to injustice. For Haight, however, this does not reduce salvation to a matter of ethics – the massive social evil in our world constitutes not merely an ethical problem but a genuinely anthropological and theological one – such unprecedented, systematic social sin demands a response at the level of the mystery of evil. This is why he can say that even for Christians, the salvation which Jesus mediates is a potential one, fulfilled only to the degree that it is taken into action. Simple faith in doctrines about Jesus confuse faith and belief and, insofar as they do not culminate in transformed action on behalf of humanity, are radically insufficient. At the same time, he does not blandly equate salvation with the elimination of social evil – he acknowledges the extreme durability of social evil and the reality that even Jesus did not end social evils in his day. Rather, commitment to responding to the human problem is itself salvific (avoiding concepts of salvation as a “yes/no” reality) – as Martin King could say to civil rights activists in 1963 that they were “masters in their own nonviolent struggle,” while they were obviously still subject to the social evil around them, so is salvation always a process, always with overcoming of social evil on the horizon, but not simply equated with that horizon.
Haight claims that in a postmodern context, it is no longer valid to use models that posit actions taking place in the interior life of God, for which we have no data. In effect, he says that what we can say about Jesus’ action for salvation must be limited to what we can say about Jesus of Nazareth, so that “transaction” theories are no longer intelligible. This also means that, since we have no data about Jesus by which to claim that all grace is the grace of Christ, we need not (cannot?) make such claims. The benefit here is that it acknowledges that God is posited as savior long before Jesus and avoids mythical-sounding arguments that Jesus of Nazareth somehow has an effect on people who have never experienced him or kerygma about him, which would go against the specifically human character of Jesus. Only God saves, and God’s universally salvific will reaches through all of time and space, so Jesus does not cause, in an unqualified sense, salvation; rather, he reveals the presence of God and proclaims a message which is preeminently against that which dehumanizes, that which negates meaning. As for the kingdom of God, which Haight sees as Jesus’ focus, while it is a problem in that it is a particularly Jewish symbol, Haight wants to make it finally about the fulfillment of the human project in a way that enables community with God and humanity, he does not want to make its existence a “yes/no” issue. For Haight, the distance between the kingdom of God and the “anti-kingdom” is always a matter of degree; wherever justice is done, wherever meaning exists in human history, there the kingdom exists, but always in tension with the injustice and meaninglessness that coexist with them. This means that Jesus is not the sine qua non of the kingdom; he proclaims the kingdom but does not inaugurate it from nothing.
Haight has to have some kind of baseline so as to avoid making any ridiculous claim valid simply as a matter of “tolerance.” Here, he affirms that what is to be saved is human freedom, which means, not choice, but self-transcendence, so that Haight seemingly ends up wanting to make self-transcendence the true measure of religious truth. While Haight argues that, a priori, other religions have the potential to reveal God/Ultimate Reality in a way that is on par with how Jesus does for Christians, he at once adds that any decisions about particular norms are to be adjudicated in a situation of dialogue, that is, a posteriori. No religion is to be taken as a whole a priori, since the movement in the direction of self-transcendence is opposed by the realities of human egoism and the finitude of reality, which inevitably are coded into religious expression. While all religions are potentially open to mediating God, and the plurality does so better than any one religion can, none does so perfectly, and in actuality it seems inevitable that all do contain structures of legitimated egoism and anti-humanity.
What of the relationship of Jesus’ mediation of God to the world religions? In Haight’s language, Jesus is normative but not constitutive – while God is genuinely how Jesus reveals God to be, and all people can find authentic revelation of God in Jesus, God is not ONLY like Jesus. In other words, while Jesus qualitatively reveals the fullness of God, he does not do so quantitatively, which Haight sees as an obvious outcome of the fact that Jesus, as an historical person, is finite and culturally limited. Haight wants, not merely to say that other religious media can mediate the God-image of Jesus, but to insist that we relativize our language about God, since any data about God is mediated by culture, therefore analogous. God can be legitimately imaged in other ways, says Haight, including dealing with the classic issue of seeing ultimate reality as impersonal, as in Taoism or Theravada Buddhism. Here, Haight says, the normal restriction of the principle of non-contradiction (one cannot simultaneously affirm something and its opposite about the same reality at the same level) does not apply, since again, any language about ultimate reality is at best analogous. However, this appears as almost an afterthought for Haight – after so much argument that God is loving and desirous of human salvation, to claim that God can also be imagined as impersonal seems to lack seriousness. This problem is not simply Haight’s, of course – theories of some common center of all religious experience has been a snakepit for the theology of religions for decades, from Hick’s Reality-centrism to Knitter’s “Soterio-centrism.” Haight has to have something at the core of his system, but in effect, while he backs off of a historically uncritical christocentrism, he ends up in a theocentrism that is just as difficult for many people to swallow.
2. In what way does Merton’s democratization of contemplation inform Catholic theories of non-violence and peacemaking?
Thomas Merton’s early years as a monk were characterized by a rather negative, dualistic understanding of the relationship of the monk to the world. Entering Gethsemani meant, for the young Merton, leaving behind aspiration, security, self-image, all the things he had sought “in the world.” In this model, the contemplative life was a sort of “spiritual dynamo,” holding the world together by the force of prayer generated, in effect making the monastery more “productive” than the world, and playing the world’s game better than the world itself. Merton used the language of the search for the “true self,” which was defined over against the falsehoods of the world – beauty, approval, autonomy, and whatever could reinforce the ego’s image of itself as independent, as powerful, as godlike. The more mature Merton, however, came to see that notions of the monastery as free of the falsehoods of the world were simply illusory – people brought their egos, their need to succeed and be praised, and their violence with them. As Merton was able to move into greater and greater solitude, first in the woodshed he called St. Ann’s, then spending days and occasional nights in the hermitage, and finally as a full-time hermit, Merton was able to see contemplation as a means of recognizing his unity with humanity, rather than his “over-againstness.” He continued to use his earlier language of true self/false self in his more mature writings, but always with an awareness of how strong were the falsehoods that lived in his own heart.
Merton’s oft-repeated term “le point vierge,” the virginal point that is our truest self, beyond the constructs of personal status and collective identity, became more and more identified with Christ, but with a humble, kenotic Christ. The solitary, for Merton, is supposed to be bored, and lonely, and question his/her usefulness since he or she is not “producing” anything. All of the constructs that usually serve for the ego to hang its hat on are challenged, as one has to face the reality that one is not disciplined, not in control, not missed by the world that is carrying on as if the solitary never existed. As the person comes to acknowledge his or her own limitedness and poverty, one is able to stand before God “naked,” that is, without need to pretend that one is other than the same old small, foolish person, or as Merton referred to himself in his final years, an “old bat.” Extending this imagery from the personal sphere to the social, Merton was aware how the collective myths of peoples and nations could authorize brutality in the name of avoiding that kind of vulnerability, in the name of a “realism” which in fact was an illusory autonomy. If communism (at that time) was purely evil, then it must be opposed, and nothing short of force will stop them, so whatever actions we take in the name of stopping them are justified. This refusal to be self-critical was diametrically opposed to Merton’s evolving understanding of contemplation.
Friends including Rosemary Ruether encouraged him to “get with it,” meaning leave the monastery and engage even more in peace work, especially when the monastic authorities censured Merton and limited his engagement with peace work. However, despite Merton’s increasing involvement in work against the war in Vietnam, he came to see his proper place in the world as at the margin, not out of contempt, but to have something to offer, a vantage point from which to see what others might miss. Merton therefore saw his monastic life as a sort of critical distancing from being so directly engaged. However, contemplation for Merton did not simply open up into criticism, but into compassion. The solitary, for Merton, is able to see that the falsehoods that live in the supporter of violence and the racist live in his/her own heart as well, but is also able to reverse that movement and acknowledge that “le point vierge” in the Other, although boarded up by ego and illusion, is the same naked Christ who is the deepest reality of the solitary him/herself. The point of his contemplative life was to transform one’s consciousness to be in line with this deepest self, crucifying the ego which demands to be the center of our lives, in favor of the “mind of Christ” who emptied himself unto death, in keeping with Paul’s “I live, though not I; Christ lives in me.” Without this kind of identification with the Other, the move to demonizing the Other was almost inevitable, even for those who called themselves “peace-loving” people, as demonstrated by the escalating hostilities on both sides of the Iron Curtain and the growing tension between the white power structure and the smoldering resentment of the Black Power movement.
Even though he supported the politics of peace groups such as the Catholic Peace Fellowship and Pax Christi, he was well aware that the danger of the peace people demonizing the other side as “warmongers” was real, which ended up in a sort of “violent pacifism.” In an era in which, Merton believed, the dominant myth was rooted in violence against communism as the manifestation of evil, to see those caught in such illusions as themselves manifestations of evil simply rearranged the furniture.
However, Merton never claimed to be an absolute pacifist, and he came to see that in order to give oneself away, one must have a self to give. For this reason he was sympathetic with revolutionary groups in Latin America and in the civil rights movement – since centuries of oppression had so crushed any sense of selfhood out of so many people, when they finally moved to claim their freedoms, it could hardly be surprising when they refused to follow a pattern of nonviolent resistance that asked them to continue to suffer indignities at the hands of their oppressors. Still, he saw such uprisings as likely to be exercises in futility, as they would likely confirm the beliefs of the oppressors that the oppressed HAD to be kept down because they were too violent to be treated otherwise.
Merton saw his time as one in which language had been systematically emptied of meaning, as regimes co-opted speech as a smoke screen for oppression. For this reason he wrote scathing expositions on the corruption of language and moved in his later poetry into the genre of “antipoetry,” which functioned for him as a way of expressing the absurd lengths to which language had been corrupted. In his “Chant to be Used in Procession Around a Site With Furnaces,” Merton’s protagonist, a numbed concentration camp commandant, can proudly claim “I made improvements,” without paying attention to the horrific context within which he made them. He ends with a similar acknowledgement of the real danger of psychic numbing on the part of Americans in Vietnam, pointing out that they were at that moment dropping bombs on friends and enemies without ever seeing what they had done.
In a similar vein, Merton was able to hold up examples of those who had stood against what he called the “mass mind”: the refusal to critically examine the popular illusions of one’s own group. Such individuals, such as Franz Jaegerstaetter, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, and Alfred Delp, although not “contemplatives” in the sense of living in monasteries, were able to set their allegiance in an identity beyond the construct of popular convention. Merton notes that such people are always threatening to the herd and are often destroyed (as were the three listed above), but bore witness to conscience that runs deeper than public moral conventions. As a foil, Merton looks to a character like Adolf Eichmann, whose statement, “My only language is officialese” bespoke a refusal to critique the falsehoods of his ego. Nevertheless, Merton was always careful to avoid turning any one group into a paragon of the demonic. Merton points out that Eichmann was disturbed at seeing what went on in Auschwitz, that he was able to do his job because he permitted himself not to see, not because he was a monster. Speaking of Klehr, a nurse in Auschwitz who killed thousands of people with injections of phenol, Merton stated that Auschwitz becomes a little worse when we recall that Klehr too was human, because it means that the shadow of inhumanity looms large over us all – who among us is truly not capable of doing monstrous things if put into the right circumstances?
Distancing from the ego, Merton was able to see peacemaking in other than simply pragmatic terms. For Merton this is essential if it is to avoid judging itself on the same standards as violence. While he certainly believed that peacemaking was pragmatic, this was a secondary concern to the fact that it bear witness to truth. Even the valuable language of human rights could, in theory, become a millstone around one’s neck if they became absolutes to be defended by any means necessary; if we create monsters out of anyone who has the potential to take away that to which we cling, we end up supporting Merton’s classic statement, “The Root of War is Fear.” Merton’s belief that nonviolence demanded the ability to suffer a certain amount of injustice could come from a belief in the dignity of humanity that is not to be clutched ruthlessly, but as a reference back to the One in whose image we are made, the truest self, which is exemplified not in clinging to ego, but in self-emptying.
5. Write an essay that describes the meanings that Genesis 1 might have had for its original audience and readers. How would you describe the relationship between those meanings and others that have been found in the text in the history of the tradition, for example, the doctrine of creation ex nihilo?
Modern scholarship generally sees the origins of GN 1 to lie most strongly with the Chaoskampf myth of the young fertility god Ba’al’s defeat of the primordial beast Yam (Sea) or Nahar (River) found in the Ugaritic texts at Ras Shamra in the early 20th century. Earlier theories, for example, Gunkel’s, that the Babylonian cosmogony, the Enuma Elish, was the source for GN 1, have been generally discarded, although the similarities are still noted. However, the Ba’al/Yam text is not cosmogonic, and GN 1 does not include a Chaoskampf motif. In addition, the general belief today is that although GN 1 has roots going back to perhaps the 10th century, it did not achieve its final form until the exilic period (6th century BC). I believe that new meanings that were nascent in the early text came to the fore in exile, as the people responded to an existential situation of the collapse of their social fabric and the political dissolution of their nation.
One theory has hints of Chaoskampf lurking in the background of GN 1, despite the fact that God does not struggle with the tehom (the primordial chaos/sea which was already in existence at the beginning of GN 1). In this model the tehom is seen as a menacing reality, not personal in the way that the salt water goddess Tiamat (a word which is etymologically related but not the origin of the Hebrew tehom) is in the Enuma Elish, but still a reality always in need of containment. Beginning with the reality of tehom, God in GN 1 gradually sets boundaries beyond which it may not cross; without these boundaries, without God’s continual vigilance, the tehom will return. Existentially, that is, the world is an inherently unsafe place, and if God ever neglects God’s watchfulness, chaos is always ready to encroach upon us and threaten our reality. This image lies behind numerous lament psalms and in Isaiah of the exile in the imagery of God delivering the people from the waters, which existentially point to chaos and meaninglessness. The two Chaoskampf texts that deal with God’s creating action in Psalms, Pss 74 and 89, both lament precisely as a way of calling God back to the precedent God set in creation; it is no accident that both texts are likely dated to early in the exilic period. Ps 74 refers to God crushing the heads of Leviathan in creation as compared with God’s silence while the Temple was being destroyed and God was being mocked. Ps 89 mentions God crushing Rahab with a mortal blow in the counter-situation of the loss of the Davidic rule.
In addition to the hints of Chaoskampf in these psalms, and its absence in GN 1, however, both texts serve as structure legitimation, respectively of Temple and kingship. Ps 89 goes so far as to say that God inaugurated kingship almost immediately after creation, contra 1 Sam 8, and even makes the king God’s son and viceroy, giving the king command over the waters – a power distinctly belonging to God. This notion of legitimation of the political or religious status quo is central for numerous cosmogonic texts in the Ancient Near East, including the Enuma Elish, which is less about cosmogony and more about the enthronement of the hero-god Marduk and, by extension, Marduk’s regent, the king of Babylon. Similarly, Pss 74 and 89 respectively legitimate the Temple and the king – for people confronted with the reality of exile, the assumption that the God of Israel and Judah has been defeated by the superior gods of Babylon might seem natural, but in the Psalms, as in GN 1, the text refuses to deny either side of reality: exile is certainly real, chaos is real, Temple and kingship have fallen, but God is still capable of acting, still available to order it all. The temptation to assume that God has lost is diverted in another direction that enables people to hold onto their identity and empowers hope that God will return to God’s promises. In addition in GN 1, the lack of explicit Chaoskampf imagery implies not only that God rules, but that nothing can oppose God. Even the great sea monsters (although Leviathan and Rahab, both mentioned in the Ras Shamra text as monsters destroyed by Ba’al, are not mentioned by name in GN 1) are created by God and declared good, not opponents of God. This follows the imagery of Ps 104, which some see as the immediate precursor to GN 1, in which Leviathan is at play in the sea which God so powerfully controls – in the words of a student, Leviathan is God’s “rubber ducky.”
In addition to giving hope that God will return to God’s pattern of bringing order (tranquility, shalom) from chaos (sea/exile), the inclusion of the Sabbath into the structure of creation means that, as much as this text is universal in the cosmology it describes (as much as that is its concern), it is also particular: the Jewish practice of Sabbath is coded into the very fabric of creation. For Jews in exile, this means that it is possible to maintain a distinct Jewish identity through the deliberate practice of customs that stand in distinction with the customs of Babylon. It is a standard belief today that numerous particularly Jewish practices emerged as more central to Jewish life precisely in exile, which would make sense in a community in search of maintaining a distinct identity. For those Jews who chose to remain in Diaspora at the end of the exile (ca. 538 BC), they were able to remain Jewish despite the fact that those things that had been seen as central in the Promised Land itself were gone.
The convention today is to read GN 1 in connection with Isaiah of the exile; the strong imagery in Deutero-Isaiah of God as sole ruler of the universe, with its language of homecoming and restoration, and with its connection to Exodus language of God “opening a way in the sea” (IS 43:16), a new meaning latent in GN 1 comes to bear. Not only is it possible to survive as Jews in exile, but it is authorized to hope for homecoming. Just as God created a habitable space in the midst of the chaos in GN 1 (admittedly the whole world, not merely Israel), so God will again make space for Israel to be Israel, although surrounded by the power of empire.
The language of humanity as made in the image of God also speaks to peoples who are acquainted with the imagery of the creation of humans in other myths. Whereas in the Enuma Elish humanity is created from the blood of the god Kingu, general of Tiamat’s forces, so that the gods can rest and be served by the humans, here humanity is made in the image of a different kind of God – by taking rest, God authorizes rest for humanity, as is evident in the practice of Sabbath and the Exodus version of the Decalogue. As Walter Brueggemann puts it, the exiles are not meant to be cogs in the machinery of empire. Although the (Solomonic) royal establishment under which the text first came into existence would not have liked that interpretation, says Brueggemann, here new possibilities are open.
Finally, GN 1 offers a vision of God’s desire for peace. Against the notion of the Chaoskampf texts, in which God creates through violence (even if it is against monsters), here there is no violence, only submission. This does not mean that chaos is not real and it is not dangerous. Contra another author, who sees the tehom as “only water,” obeying God’s commands (or, according to his reading of the Hebrew jussive tense, God’s suggestions), it seems to me that in exile, the water is not merely water – chaos is real, and it is scary, but when God decides to take action, God’s will reigns without violence. Violence does not come until GN 4, and then through human initiative. Peace stands at the head of the Biblical witness and should be held in tension with later stories of violence commanded or even done by God.
(*As a side note, having lived through Hurricane Katrina, I read this story with a new seriousness. The waters of chaos indeed swirled through our homes and our lives, and it was a powerful experience to be able to discuss with my students (many of whom had lost their homes, all their possessions, and their city) the assertion that God creates order out of chaos, and that hope for going home is authorized by these texts.*)
Against this social-existential reading, to me the tradition of reading GN 1 as history and/or science, as in a creationist approach, flattens the text. To reduce story that deals with the making of meaning in our lives down to data about when physical objects came into existence misses the goal of having something to say to our lives. It ends up putting different spheres of knowing in competition, so that science or history are seen as undercutting the possibility of believing in a God, and therefore presumably believing in meaning or depth in human life. While the modern audience has trouble with some of the parts of the story that do not fit expectations, for example the pre-existent chaos, rarely do people acknowledge that the cosmology described in GN 1, with its solid firmament and flat earth surrounded on all sides by water, is completely untenable today. On the other hand, while the doctrine of creation ex nihilo affirms the dependence of all on God for existence, and delegitimating claims to human finality as does GN 1, it loses the power to respond in situations in need of hope (e.g. exile). It is to be noted that texts like this one, like the Enuma Elish, asserting power and control, often come not at moments of power, but at moments of weakness – one theory today is that the Enuma Elish was formulated at an ebb of Babylonian power – when people need to be authorized to hope beyond the experience “on the ground,” which is too often experience of destruction and loss. Finally, the problem of theodicy looms large in both. No reason is given for the existence of chaos in the first place in GN 1 (it is simply there, simply assumed), and if ever God’s attention slips, chaos is on hand to return and devour. On the other hand, there is a goodness to the whole affair, rest is authorized and creation can even endure without God needing to constantly work at holding it together – watchfulness suffices. Similarly in the notion of creation ex nihilo, when God is the only god on the scene, the problem of negativity beyond human causes still remains. Why create and maintain that which is so firmly negative? Does existence have its own autonomy, can it be genuinely random and open-ended, as so much of the biological and astronomical data today suggest?
1. Summarize Roger Haight’s Spirit Christology in regard to the way it articulates the relationship of Jesus to the world religions. What do you perceive to be the value of Haight’s distinctive approach, but what also do you perceive to be its challenges and limitations?
Haight’s genetic approach to Christology attempts to understand the foundational experiences that undergirded the development of the New Testament and the later Christological formulations of the early councils. Against trying to harmonize all of the different models of Christology in the New Testament or to favor one as the premier model, as he would say has been done with the Logos model for centuries, he prefers to see all of them as metaphorical and poetic statements which point to the reality that people encounter God and God’s salvation in Jesus. Other theologians prefer to see the claim that Jesus is unique Son of God at the center of the New Testament, but for Haight, this both focuses too much on Jesus, who did not focus on himself but on God, and it neglects the reality that people ask the Christological questions because of the soteriological experience. Haight’s preferred model for this is of God as Spirit, which he sees as poetic language for God as God is present in the world, rather than as strictly hypostatic language. The benefit here is that Haight does not dismiss Logos language, but places it in dialogue with other Christologies. This opens the door for other manifestations of the Spirit to the world, but it is hard to qualify “degrees” of the presence of the Spirit, so it is unclear what makes Jesus different from the prophet Jeremiah or Archbishop Oscar Romero.
Haight has at the center of his method two basic claims: God desires the salvation of all, and there is no unmediated experience of God. This means that Haight has a hard time with the “scandal of particularity” in the sense of seeing God as particularly privileging one group or religion or moment in history. In looking at the world religions, Haight says that it is to be expected that there would be many, and widely different, ways of speaking about the revelation of the divine, precisely because the experience of God comes precisely through the mediation of the cultures of the world, which obviously are extremely diverse. One significant issue here is that numerous religions do not seem to be reaching out for a salvation that is in any serious way like what Christians claim. Haight attempts to deal with this by saying that the true centerpiece of religion is the experience of negativity: meaninglessness in human history, finitude, suffering, death, and massive social evil. The concern for salvation which Haight says drives all religious thought is in fact not necessarily a concern for afterlife or divine deliverance but a concern for the experience of negativity. Just as Jesus is important because people experience in him the presence of God and a response to the problem of negativity, so for the other religions in their own distinct ways.
In keeping with Haight’s desire to respond to such negativity, he warns that any model of salvation must deal with earthly reality, or in his terms, liberation. He particularly addresses the modern Western notion of an individualistic salvation, which to his mind enables refusal to address the reality of the suffering in the world and as such proves correct the analysis of figures like Marx who see religion blinding or numbing people to injustice. For Haight, however, this does not reduce salvation to a matter of ethics – the massive social evil in our world constitutes not merely an ethical problem but a genuinely anthropological and theological one – such unprecedented, systematic social sin demands a response at the level of the mystery of evil. This is why he can say that even for Christians, the salvation which Jesus mediates is a potential one, fulfilled only to the degree that it is taken into action. Simple faith in doctrines about Jesus confuse faith and belief and, insofar as they do not culminate in transformed action on behalf of humanity, are radically insufficient. At the same time, he does not blandly equate salvation with the elimination of social evil – he acknowledges the extreme durability of social evil and the reality that even Jesus did not end social evils in his day. Rather, commitment to responding to the human problem is itself salvific (avoiding concepts of salvation as a “yes/no” reality) – as Martin King could say to civil rights activists in 1963 that they were “masters in their own nonviolent struggle,” while they were obviously still subject to the social evil around them, so is salvation always a process, always with overcoming of social evil on the horizon, but not simply equated with that horizon.
Haight claims that in a postmodern context, it is no longer valid to use models that posit actions taking place in the interior life of God, for which we have no data. In effect, he says that what we can say about Jesus’ action for salvation must be limited to what we can say about Jesus of Nazareth, so that “transaction” theories are no longer intelligible. This also means that, since we have no data about Jesus by which to claim that all grace is the grace of Christ, we need not (cannot?) make such claims. The benefit here is that it acknowledges that God is posited as savior long before Jesus and avoids mythical-sounding arguments that Jesus of Nazareth somehow has an effect on people who have never experienced him or kerygma about him, which would go against the specifically human character of Jesus. Only God saves, and God’s universally salvific will reaches through all of time and space, so Jesus does not cause, in an unqualified sense, salvation; rather, he reveals the presence of God and proclaims a message which is preeminently against that which dehumanizes, that which negates meaning. As for the kingdom of God, which Haight sees as Jesus’ focus, while it is a problem in that it is a particularly Jewish symbol, Haight wants to make it finally about the fulfillment of the human project in a way that enables community with God and humanity, he does not want to make its existence a “yes/no” issue. For Haight, the distance between the kingdom of God and the “anti-kingdom” is always a matter of degree; wherever justice is done, wherever meaning exists in human history, there the kingdom exists, but always in tension with the injustice and meaninglessness that coexist with them. This means that Jesus is not the sine qua non of the kingdom; he proclaims the kingdom but does not inaugurate it from nothing.
Haight has to have some kind of baseline so as to avoid making any ridiculous claim valid simply as a matter of “tolerance.” Here, he affirms that what is to be saved is human freedom, which means, not choice, but self-transcendence, so that Haight seemingly ends up wanting to make self-transcendence the true measure of religious truth. While Haight argues that, a priori, other religions have the potential to reveal God/Ultimate Reality in a way that is on par with how Jesus does for Christians, he at once adds that any decisions about particular norms are to be adjudicated in a situation of dialogue, that is, a posteriori. No religion is to be taken as a whole a priori, since the movement in the direction of self-transcendence is opposed by the realities of human egoism and the finitude of reality, which inevitably are coded into religious expression. While all religions are potentially open to mediating God, and the plurality does so better than any one religion can, none does so perfectly, and in actuality it seems inevitable that all do contain structures of legitimated egoism and anti-humanity.
What of the relationship of Jesus’ mediation of God to the world religions? In Haight’s language, Jesus is normative but not constitutive – while God is genuinely how Jesus reveals God to be, and all people can find authentic revelation of God in Jesus, God is not ONLY like Jesus. In other words, while Jesus qualitatively reveals the fullness of God, he does not do so quantitatively, which Haight sees as an obvious outcome of the fact that Jesus, as an historical person, is finite and culturally limited. Haight wants, not merely to say that other religious media can mediate the God-image of Jesus, but to insist that we relativize our language about God, since any data about God is mediated by culture, therefore analogous. God can be legitimately imaged in other ways, says Haight, including dealing with the classic issue of seeing ultimate reality as impersonal, as in Taoism or Theravada Buddhism. Here, Haight says, the normal restriction of the principle of non-contradiction (one cannot simultaneously affirm something and its opposite about the same reality at the same level) does not apply, since again, any language about ultimate reality is at best analogous. However, this appears as almost an afterthought for Haight – after so much argument that God is loving and desirous of human salvation, to claim that God can also be imagined as impersonal seems to lack seriousness. This problem is not simply Haight’s, of course – theories of some common center of all religious experience has been a snakepit for the theology of religions for decades, from Hick’s Reality-centrism to Knitter’s “Soterio-centrism.” Haight has to have something at the core of his system, but in effect, while he backs off of a historically uncritical christocentrism, he ends up in a theocentrism that is just as difficult for many people to swallow.
2. In what way does Merton’s democratization of contemplation inform Catholic theories of non-violence and peacemaking?
Thomas Merton’s early years as a monk were characterized by a rather negative, dualistic understanding of the relationship of the monk to the world. Entering Gethsemani meant, for the young Merton, leaving behind aspiration, security, self-image, all the things he had sought “in the world.” In this model, the contemplative life was a sort of “spiritual dynamo,” holding the world together by the force of prayer generated, in effect making the monastery more “productive” than the world, and playing the world’s game better than the world itself. Merton used the language of the search for the “true self,” which was defined over against the falsehoods of the world – beauty, approval, autonomy, and whatever could reinforce the ego’s image of itself as independent, as powerful, as godlike. The more mature Merton, however, came to see that notions of the monastery as free of the falsehoods of the world were simply illusory – people brought their egos, their need to succeed and be praised, and their violence with them. As Merton was able to move into greater and greater solitude, first in the woodshed he called St. Ann’s, then spending days and occasional nights in the hermitage, and finally as a full-time hermit, Merton was able to see contemplation as a means of recognizing his unity with humanity, rather than his “over-againstness.” He continued to use his earlier language of true self/false self in his more mature writings, but always with an awareness of how strong were the falsehoods that lived in his own heart.
Merton’s oft-repeated term “le point vierge,” the virginal point that is our truest self, beyond the constructs of personal status and collective identity, became more and more identified with Christ, but with a humble, kenotic Christ. The solitary, for Merton, is supposed to be bored, and lonely, and question his/her usefulness since he or she is not “producing” anything. All of the constructs that usually serve for the ego to hang its hat on are challenged, as one has to face the reality that one is not disciplined, not in control, not missed by the world that is carrying on as if the solitary never existed. As the person comes to acknowledge his or her own limitedness and poverty, one is able to stand before God “naked,” that is, without need to pretend that one is other than the same old small, foolish person, or as Merton referred to himself in his final years, an “old bat.” Extending this imagery from the personal sphere to the social, Merton was aware how the collective myths of peoples and nations could authorize brutality in the name of avoiding that kind of vulnerability, in the name of a “realism” which in fact was an illusory autonomy. If communism (at that time) was purely evil, then it must be opposed, and nothing short of force will stop them, so whatever actions we take in the name of stopping them are justified. This refusal to be self-critical was diametrically opposed to Merton’s evolving understanding of contemplation.
Friends including Rosemary Ruether encouraged him to “get with it,” meaning leave the monastery and engage even more in peace work, especially when the monastic authorities censured Merton and limited his engagement with peace work. However, despite Merton’s increasing involvement in work against the war in Vietnam, he came to see his proper place in the world as at the margin, not out of contempt, but to have something to offer, a vantage point from which to see what others might miss. Merton therefore saw his monastic life as a sort of critical distancing from being so directly engaged. However, contemplation for Merton did not simply open up into criticism, but into compassion. The solitary, for Merton, is able to see that the falsehoods that live in the supporter of violence and the racist live in his/her own heart as well, but is also able to reverse that movement and acknowledge that “le point vierge” in the Other, although boarded up by ego and illusion, is the same naked Christ who is the deepest reality of the solitary him/herself. The point of his contemplative life was to transform one’s consciousness to be in line with this deepest self, crucifying the ego which demands to be the center of our lives, in favor of the “mind of Christ” who emptied himself unto death, in keeping with Paul’s “I live, though not I; Christ lives in me.” Without this kind of identification with the Other, the move to demonizing the Other was almost inevitable, even for those who called themselves “peace-loving” people, as demonstrated by the escalating hostilities on both sides of the Iron Curtain and the growing tension between the white power structure and the smoldering resentment of the Black Power movement.
Even though he supported the politics of peace groups such as the Catholic Peace Fellowship and Pax Christi, he was well aware that the danger of the peace people demonizing the other side as “warmongers” was real, which ended up in a sort of “violent pacifism.” In an era in which, Merton believed, the dominant myth was rooted in violence against communism as the manifestation of evil, to see those caught in such illusions as themselves manifestations of evil simply rearranged the furniture.
However, Merton never claimed to be an absolute pacifist, and he came to see that in order to give oneself away, one must have a self to give. For this reason he was sympathetic with revolutionary groups in Latin America and in the civil rights movement – since centuries of oppression had so crushed any sense of selfhood out of so many people, when they finally moved to claim their freedoms, it could hardly be surprising when they refused to follow a pattern of nonviolent resistance that asked them to continue to suffer indignities at the hands of their oppressors. Still, he saw such uprisings as likely to be exercises in futility, as they would likely confirm the beliefs of the oppressors that the oppressed HAD to be kept down because they were too violent to be treated otherwise.
Merton saw his time as one in which language had been systematically emptied of meaning, as regimes co-opted speech as a smoke screen for oppression. For this reason he wrote scathing expositions on the corruption of language and moved in his later poetry into the genre of “antipoetry,” which functioned for him as a way of expressing the absurd lengths to which language had been corrupted. In his “Chant to be Used in Procession Around a Site With Furnaces,” Merton’s protagonist, a numbed concentration camp commandant, can proudly claim “I made improvements,” without paying attention to the horrific context within which he made them. He ends with a similar acknowledgement of the real danger of psychic numbing on the part of Americans in Vietnam, pointing out that they were at that moment dropping bombs on friends and enemies without ever seeing what they had done.
In a similar vein, Merton was able to hold up examples of those who had stood against what he called the “mass mind”: the refusal to critically examine the popular illusions of one’s own group. Such individuals, such as Franz Jaegerstaetter, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, and Alfred Delp, although not “contemplatives” in the sense of living in monasteries, were able to set their allegiance in an identity beyond the construct of popular convention. Merton notes that such people are always threatening to the herd and are often destroyed (as were the three listed above), but bore witness to conscience that runs deeper than public moral conventions. As a foil, Merton looks to a character like Adolf Eichmann, whose statement, “My only language is officialese” bespoke a refusal to critique the falsehoods of his ego. Nevertheless, Merton was always careful to avoid turning any one group into a paragon of the demonic. Merton points out that Eichmann was disturbed at seeing what went on in Auschwitz, that he was able to do his job because he permitted himself not to see, not because he was a monster. Speaking of Klehr, a nurse in Auschwitz who killed thousands of people with injections of phenol, Merton stated that Auschwitz becomes a little worse when we recall that Klehr too was human, because it means that the shadow of inhumanity looms large over us all – who among us is truly not capable of doing monstrous things if put into the right circumstances?
Distancing from the ego, Merton was able to see peacemaking in other than simply pragmatic terms. For Merton this is essential if it is to avoid judging itself on the same standards as violence. While he certainly believed that peacemaking was pragmatic, this was a secondary concern to the fact that it bear witness to truth. Even the valuable language of human rights could, in theory, become a millstone around one’s neck if they became absolutes to be defended by any means necessary; if we create monsters out of anyone who has the potential to take away that to which we cling, we end up supporting Merton’s classic statement, “The Root of War is Fear.” Merton’s belief that nonviolence demanded the ability to suffer a certain amount of injustice could come from a belief in the dignity of humanity that is not to be clutched ruthlessly, but as a reference back to the One in whose image we are made, the truest self, which is exemplified not in clinging to ego, but in self-emptying.
5. Write an essay that describes the meanings that Genesis 1 might have had for its original audience and readers. How would you describe the relationship between those meanings and others that have been found in the text in the history of the tradition, for example, the doctrine of creation ex nihilo?
Modern scholarship generally sees the origins of GN 1 to lie most strongly with the Chaoskampf myth of the young fertility god Ba’al’s defeat of the primordial beast Yam (Sea) or Nahar (River) found in the Ugaritic texts at Ras Shamra in the early 20th century. Earlier theories, for example, Gunkel’s, that the Babylonian cosmogony, the Enuma Elish, was the source for GN 1, have been generally discarded, although the similarities are still noted. However, the Ba’al/Yam text is not cosmogonic, and GN 1 does not include a Chaoskampf motif. In addition, the general belief today is that although GN 1 has roots going back to perhaps the 10th century, it did not achieve its final form until the exilic period (6th century BC). I believe that new meanings that were nascent in the early text came to the fore in exile, as the people responded to an existential situation of the collapse of their social fabric and the political dissolution of their nation.
One theory has hints of Chaoskampf lurking in the background of GN 1, despite the fact that God does not struggle with the tehom (the primordial chaos/sea which was already in existence at the beginning of GN 1). In this model the tehom is seen as a menacing reality, not personal in the way that the salt water goddess Tiamat (a word which is etymologically related but not the origin of the Hebrew tehom) is in the Enuma Elish, but still a reality always in need of containment. Beginning with the reality of tehom, God in GN 1 gradually sets boundaries beyond which it may not cross; without these boundaries, without God’s continual vigilance, the tehom will return. Existentially, that is, the world is an inherently unsafe place, and if God ever neglects God’s watchfulness, chaos is always ready to encroach upon us and threaten our reality. This image lies behind numerous lament psalms and in Isaiah of the exile in the imagery of God delivering the people from the waters, which existentially point to chaos and meaninglessness. The two Chaoskampf texts that deal with God’s creating action in Psalms, Pss 74 and 89, both lament precisely as a way of calling God back to the precedent God set in creation; it is no accident that both texts are likely dated to early in the exilic period. Ps 74 refers to God crushing the heads of Leviathan in creation as compared with God’s silence while the Temple was being destroyed and God was being mocked. Ps 89 mentions God crushing Rahab with a mortal blow in the counter-situation of the loss of the Davidic rule.
In addition to the hints of Chaoskampf in these psalms, and its absence in GN 1, however, both texts serve as structure legitimation, respectively of Temple and kingship. Ps 89 goes so far as to say that God inaugurated kingship almost immediately after creation, contra 1 Sam 8, and even makes the king God’s son and viceroy, giving the king command over the waters – a power distinctly belonging to God. This notion of legitimation of the political or religious status quo is central for numerous cosmogonic texts in the Ancient Near East, including the Enuma Elish, which is less about cosmogony and more about the enthronement of the hero-god Marduk and, by extension, Marduk’s regent, the king of Babylon. Similarly, Pss 74 and 89 respectively legitimate the Temple and the king – for people confronted with the reality of exile, the assumption that the God of Israel and Judah has been defeated by the superior gods of Babylon might seem natural, but in the Psalms, as in GN 1, the text refuses to deny either side of reality: exile is certainly real, chaos is real, Temple and kingship have fallen, but God is still capable of acting, still available to order it all. The temptation to assume that God has lost is diverted in another direction that enables people to hold onto their identity and empowers hope that God will return to God’s promises. In addition in GN 1, the lack of explicit Chaoskampf imagery implies not only that God rules, but that nothing can oppose God. Even the great sea monsters (although Leviathan and Rahab, both mentioned in the Ras Shamra text as monsters destroyed by Ba’al, are not mentioned by name in GN 1) are created by God and declared good, not opponents of God. This follows the imagery of Ps 104, which some see as the immediate precursor to GN 1, in which Leviathan is at play in the sea which God so powerfully controls – in the words of a student, Leviathan is God’s “rubber ducky.”
In addition to giving hope that God will return to God’s pattern of bringing order (tranquility, shalom) from chaos (sea/exile), the inclusion of the Sabbath into the structure of creation means that, as much as this text is universal in the cosmology it describes (as much as that is its concern), it is also particular: the Jewish practice of Sabbath is coded into the very fabric of creation. For Jews in exile, this means that it is possible to maintain a distinct Jewish identity through the deliberate practice of customs that stand in distinction with the customs of Babylon. It is a standard belief today that numerous particularly Jewish practices emerged as more central to Jewish life precisely in exile, which would make sense in a community in search of maintaining a distinct identity. For those Jews who chose to remain in Diaspora at the end of the exile (ca. 538 BC), they were able to remain Jewish despite the fact that those things that had been seen as central in the Promised Land itself were gone.
The convention today is to read GN 1 in connection with Isaiah of the exile; the strong imagery in Deutero-Isaiah of God as sole ruler of the universe, with its language of homecoming and restoration, and with its connection to Exodus language of God “opening a way in the sea” (IS 43:16), a new meaning latent in GN 1 comes to bear. Not only is it possible to survive as Jews in exile, but it is authorized to hope for homecoming. Just as God created a habitable space in the midst of the chaos in GN 1 (admittedly the whole world, not merely Israel), so God will again make space for Israel to be Israel, although surrounded by the power of empire.
The language of humanity as made in the image of God also speaks to peoples who are acquainted with the imagery of the creation of humans in other myths. Whereas in the Enuma Elish humanity is created from the blood of the god Kingu, general of Tiamat’s forces, so that the gods can rest and be served by the humans, here humanity is made in the image of a different kind of God – by taking rest, God authorizes rest for humanity, as is evident in the practice of Sabbath and the Exodus version of the Decalogue. As Walter Brueggemann puts it, the exiles are not meant to be cogs in the machinery of empire. Although the (Solomonic) royal establishment under which the text first came into existence would not have liked that interpretation, says Brueggemann, here new possibilities are open.
Finally, GN 1 offers a vision of God’s desire for peace. Against the notion of the Chaoskampf texts, in which God creates through violence (even if it is against monsters), here there is no violence, only submission. This does not mean that chaos is not real and it is not dangerous. Contra another author, who sees the tehom as “only water,” obeying God’s commands (or, according to his reading of the Hebrew jussive tense, God’s suggestions), it seems to me that in exile, the water is not merely water – chaos is real, and it is scary, but when God decides to take action, God’s will reigns without violence. Violence does not come until GN 4, and then through human initiative. Peace stands at the head of the Biblical witness and should be held in tension with later stories of violence commanded or even done by God.
(*As a side note, having lived through Hurricane Katrina, I read this story with a new seriousness. The waters of chaos indeed swirled through our homes and our lives, and it was a powerful experience to be able to discuss with my students (many of whom had lost their homes, all their possessions, and their city) the assertion that God creates order out of chaos, and that hope for going home is authorized by these texts.*)
Against this social-existential reading, to me the tradition of reading GN 1 as history and/or science, as in a creationist approach, flattens the text. To reduce story that deals with the making of meaning in our lives down to data about when physical objects came into existence misses the goal of having something to say to our lives. It ends up putting different spheres of knowing in competition, so that science or history are seen as undercutting the possibility of believing in a God, and therefore presumably believing in meaning or depth in human life. While the modern audience has trouble with some of the parts of the story that do not fit expectations, for example the pre-existent chaos, rarely do people acknowledge that the cosmology described in GN 1, with its solid firmament and flat earth surrounded on all sides by water, is completely untenable today. On the other hand, while the doctrine of creation ex nihilo affirms the dependence of all on God for existence, and delegitimating claims to human finality as does GN 1, it loses the power to respond in situations in need of hope (e.g. exile). It is to be noted that texts like this one, like the Enuma Elish, asserting power and control, often come not at moments of power, but at moments of weakness – one theory today is that the Enuma Elish was formulated at an ebb of Babylonian power – when people need to be authorized to hope beyond the experience “on the ground,” which is too often experience of destruction and loss. Finally, the problem of theodicy looms large in both. No reason is given for the existence of chaos in the first place in GN 1 (it is simply there, simply assumed), and if ever God’s attention slips, chaos is on hand to return and devour. On the other hand, there is a goodness to the whole affair, rest is authorized and creation can even endure without God needing to constantly work at holding it together – watchfulness suffices. Similarly in the notion of creation ex nihilo, when God is the only god on the scene, the problem of negativity beyond human causes still remains. Why create and maintain that which is so firmly negative? Does existence have its own autonomy, can it be genuinely random and open-ended, as so much of the biological and astronomical data today suggest?
retreat notes -- 1
(*I wrote this in longhand while I was on retreat, and am now typing it out, so the dates don't match up.*)
On retreat -- Windridge Solitude - 29 July 2007
I came home yesterday from Notre Dame, and noticed with some chagrin that the serenity that I felt while I was there disappeared as soon as I returned to the world of bad drivers and poorly managed restaurants. All it took was being stuck in a car for a few hours while hungry and tired to make me lose my cool, which is discouraging from the standpoint of making progress in the spiritual life. All the talk about true self and emptiness and whatever falls by the wayside so easily...
(*Case in point: I stopped in Pontiac, IL, a little one-horse town along I-55, looking for a place to eat. I ended up in a turning lane, but I didn't want to turn -- it would have taken me who-knows-where with no easy way to get back -- so I hung around at the green arrow for 5 seconds or so until the green light came on to go straight, and I went straight ahead to get to a restaurant. A guy followed me into the parking lot to fuss at me, implying that he was an off-duty cop and he would have ticketed me had he been on duty. His daughter made faces at me from the passenger seat the whole while, presumably either to make fun of me for getting fussed at, or to make fun of her dad for raising a ruckus. Anyway, I brushed the guy off rather rudely, then, not finding vegetarian fare at the restaurant, I self-righteously shook the dust of Pontiac from my feet in protest and sped off to the next exit in search of lunch. Me and my amazing performing ego...*)
I just got back into St. Louis last night, and I've been living out of a suitcase all summer, so part of me wasn't really excited about turning right back around and leaving for retreat, but a big part of me wanted the down time. I went last night and bought what I hoped would be enough food to last me 5 days, and this morning I got up early and left. I arrived at the retreat center about 9:45 and was met by one of the sisters, a very small woman in her 50s. We loaded my stuff into their Mule, a sort of dune-buggy/golf cart hybrid, and brought it out to the hermitage where I was to stay, then came back to the main house for mass. The five women here, I found out, are all former members of other religious orders -- two former Dominicans and three former Pallotines -- who had desired greater solitude than their communities were able to let them have. Given my own increasing desire for solitude over the past few years, the setup they created piqued my curiosity. More on that in a moment...
Mass consisted of 9 of us: the five sisters, another retreatant (an SSND), myself and the priest, and Toby, their ancient, deaf dog, who padded gamely around the chapel the whole time. The mass had a marvelous, simple spirit that said a lot about the openness that the community members have with each other. Afterwards, we sat around and chatted a bit before the sister who welcomed me took me on a brief tour of the grounds, explained the amenities of my hermitage, and left.
There are three hermitages on site for guests, and each has everything a retreatant could want: cooking utensils, oven, CD player, couch/futon, screened-in porch, deck chair, even a fully stocked mini BBQ grill. There is a lake stocked with fish (and fishing equipment for those who wish to catch their dinner), a hammock, lots of meadows and walking trails, and a modest library of spiritual literature, including an impressive collection of works by or about Thomas Merton (!).
After I stowed all my things, I settled in to the quiet, gearing myself up for 5 days without human communication. It seems like an axion to me that the ego (or at least my ego) is going to try to find something to distract itself from all this silence, and today it was concerns about food. I kept coming back to wondering if I had enough food for the week, if I would have to ration, if I would be able to leave to go to a supermarket if I ran out of food, and all this other stupid stuff that had to be my ego just getting scared by the quiet. In reality, I brought enough food for an army. (*Since I am on the subject, let me just mention the joy of having simple, fresh foods here. While I was at Notre Dame, I saw an article on avocados in some food magazine, and I have been craving avocados ever since, so I stocked up before I came here. Lunch this afternoon was a big piece of fresh whole-grain bread, a little cheese, and an extremely ripe avocado that melted like butter in my mouth. Marvelous.*)
The rest of the day alternated between periods of meditation and reading or walking around. I walked to the pond for a little while, fed the fish with some of the dog food they keep in a bug 5-gallon bucket for that purpose, and drained the water out of the little boat they have by the water's edge. Tomorrow I'll o paddle around if the weather stays nice. Mostly, though, I just sat still. I will do some work on my class, and I would like to read some of the stuff they have here on the eremitic life and on Merton, but I don't want this to become simply a time to be left alone so I can read. Even reading about contemplation is just as much a distraction as anything else if it keeps me from actually being still. Anyway, there is a sense of "rightness" about this place. Before Hurricane Katrina, I used to imagine someday being able to spend more time at the lodge in Bay St. Louis, even with an eye toward a semi-hermit life. That lodge doesn't exist any more, but I still am interested in more solitude down the road. There is certainly plenty of precedent with the monastic orders and even the mendicants, but is that compatible with an apostolic order? These women didn't seem to think so (even among the Dominican women, who are technically mendicants), but their persistence in following the Spirit led to the development of this magnificent place. Of course, given my work schedule, I already have a certain measure of solitude -- time in the afternoons in my office when students are still in class, late nights when I come home and everyone else is asleep -- but I want to keep that kind of space a priority and not merely a happy accident of my work situation. Merton would probably say that solitude is not about liking the quiet, but about the search for God. Well and good, but is it ok to like the quiet too?
Mercy within mercy within mercy...
On retreat -- Windridge Solitude - 29 July 2007
I came home yesterday from Notre Dame, and noticed with some chagrin that the serenity that I felt while I was there disappeared as soon as I returned to the world of bad drivers and poorly managed restaurants. All it took was being stuck in a car for a few hours while hungry and tired to make me lose my cool, which is discouraging from the standpoint of making progress in the spiritual life. All the talk about true self and emptiness and whatever falls by the wayside so easily...
(*Case in point: I stopped in Pontiac, IL, a little one-horse town along I-55, looking for a place to eat. I ended up in a turning lane, but I didn't want to turn -- it would have taken me who-knows-where with no easy way to get back -- so I hung around at the green arrow for 5 seconds or so until the green light came on to go straight, and I went straight ahead to get to a restaurant. A guy followed me into the parking lot to fuss at me, implying that he was an off-duty cop and he would have ticketed me had he been on duty. His daughter made faces at me from the passenger seat the whole while, presumably either to make fun of me for getting fussed at, or to make fun of her dad for raising a ruckus. Anyway, I brushed the guy off rather rudely, then, not finding vegetarian fare at the restaurant, I self-righteously shook the dust of Pontiac from my feet in protest and sped off to the next exit in search of lunch. Me and my amazing performing ego...*)
I just got back into St. Louis last night, and I've been living out of a suitcase all summer, so part of me wasn't really excited about turning right back around and leaving for retreat, but a big part of me wanted the down time. I went last night and bought what I hoped would be enough food to last me 5 days, and this morning I got up early and left. I arrived at the retreat center about 9:45 and was met by one of the sisters, a very small woman in her 50s. We loaded my stuff into their Mule, a sort of dune-buggy/golf cart hybrid, and brought it out to the hermitage where I was to stay, then came back to the main house for mass. The five women here, I found out, are all former members of other religious orders -- two former Dominicans and three former Pallotines -- who had desired greater solitude than their communities were able to let them have. Given my own increasing desire for solitude over the past few years, the setup they created piqued my curiosity. More on that in a moment...
Mass consisted of 9 of us: the five sisters, another retreatant (an SSND), myself and the priest, and Toby, their ancient, deaf dog, who padded gamely around the chapel the whole time. The mass had a marvelous, simple spirit that said a lot about the openness that the community members have with each other. Afterwards, we sat around and chatted a bit before the sister who welcomed me took me on a brief tour of the grounds, explained the amenities of my hermitage, and left.
There are three hermitages on site for guests, and each has everything a retreatant could want: cooking utensils, oven, CD player, couch/futon, screened-in porch, deck chair, even a fully stocked mini BBQ grill. There is a lake stocked with fish (and fishing equipment for those who wish to catch their dinner), a hammock, lots of meadows and walking trails, and a modest library of spiritual literature, including an impressive collection of works by or about Thomas Merton (!).
After I stowed all my things, I settled in to the quiet, gearing myself up for 5 days without human communication. It seems like an axion to me that the ego (or at least my ego) is going to try to find something to distract itself from all this silence, and today it was concerns about food. I kept coming back to wondering if I had enough food for the week, if I would have to ration, if I would be able to leave to go to a supermarket if I ran out of food, and all this other stupid stuff that had to be my ego just getting scared by the quiet. In reality, I brought enough food for an army. (*Since I am on the subject, let me just mention the joy of having simple, fresh foods here. While I was at Notre Dame, I saw an article on avocados in some food magazine, and I have been craving avocados ever since, so I stocked up before I came here. Lunch this afternoon was a big piece of fresh whole-grain bread, a little cheese, and an extremely ripe avocado that melted like butter in my mouth. Marvelous.*)
The rest of the day alternated between periods of meditation and reading or walking around. I walked to the pond for a little while, fed the fish with some of the dog food they keep in a bug 5-gallon bucket for that purpose, and drained the water out of the little boat they have by the water's edge. Tomorrow I'll o paddle around if the weather stays nice. Mostly, though, I just sat still. I will do some work on my class, and I would like to read some of the stuff they have here on the eremitic life and on Merton, but I don't want this to become simply a time to be left alone so I can read. Even reading about contemplation is just as much a distraction as anything else if it keeps me from actually being still. Anyway, there is a sense of "rightness" about this place. Before Hurricane Katrina, I used to imagine someday being able to spend more time at the lodge in Bay St. Louis, even with an eye toward a semi-hermit life. That lodge doesn't exist any more, but I still am interested in more solitude down the road. There is certainly plenty of precedent with the monastic orders and even the mendicants, but is that compatible with an apostolic order? These women didn't seem to think so (even among the Dominican women, who are technically mendicants), but their persistence in following the Spirit led to the development of this magnificent place. Of course, given my work schedule, I already have a certain measure of solitude -- time in the afternoons in my office when students are still in class, late nights when I come home and everyone else is asleep -- but I want to keep that kind of space a priority and not merely a happy accident of my work situation. Merton would probably say that solitude is not about liking the quiet, but about the search for God. Well and good, but is it ok to like the quiet too?
Mercy within mercy within mercy...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)