The semester here is almost over, so transitions are going on everywhere. Seniors are about to graduate, looking ahead to jobs or grad school or travel or volunteer programs. Students who have been studying abroad are coming home, and students who will be studying abroad are preparing to be gone for a semester or a year. We're interviewing new people for open positions, and saying goodbye to people who are leaving them open. I am loath to admit it, but one of the emotions I have been feeling in all of it, with some consistency, is envy: envy at the chance to spend a semester touring Europe, to be 24 and done with a master's degree, to be off to El Salvador for school. I can't even figure it out, since I have my own set of enviable blessings this summer and next year: a month of immersion in Haiti, another solid month of reading and thinking at Notre Dame, the conclusion of my master's work, teaching in the fall, openness to doctoral work down the road (whenever I am ready, I suspect). Is this something wrong with me, or is it another part of the tangle of illusions and desires that is the human condition? No matter how much I have, I can always find someone to envy. Lord, save me from my own voracious ego, from my need to be more, have more, do more.
Mercy within mercy within mercy...
Thursday, May 3, 2007
Monday, April 30, 2007
Into Great Silence
Boy, has it been a long time since I have posted something. I’ve had a few things on my mind to write about, but never enough time! Saturday evening I went to see the film Into Great Silence (Die Große Stille), a sort of meditative look at life in the Grande Chartreuse, the motherhouse of the Carthusian Order. The Carthusians are one of the few orders of hermits in the Catholic Church, and their life is lived almost entirely in silence. The film is nearly three hours long, and it is not a documentary, since no one really speaks to the camera or talks about being a Carthusian. Rather, it is simply a series of prolonged camera shots on different moments in their life – watching them at prayer, or feeding the cats, or sawing firewood. While I have no desire to become a Carthusian, the deep symbols and the earthy simplicity of their lives touches something archetypal in me as a religious, and perhaps in me simply as a human being. The film, like the monastery itself, was very much what the Zen tradition would call shibumi – simple, understated elegance, not beauty in the usual “prettiness” sense of the word, but like the Velveteen Rabbit when he becomes “Real” even though he is worn and threadbare. The director switched back and forth between normal film and some grainy old film that looked like the stuff they used in the 1960s, presumably for symbolic reasons that could be elaborated in several ways. Several scenes and shots of certain scripture texts were repeated throughout the whole affair – the same guy at prayer in his cell a few times, the same bowl of fruit on one of the monk’s tables again and again, the monks ringing the bells calling the brothers to prayer. What a marvelous way to symbolize their lives – repetition, pattern, a sense of eternity in the cycles of their lives. Seeing one of the old men shuffling around the halls, knowing that the young monks will one day be like them, making their creaky way through their daily tasks, the sense of timelessness of the place encompasses and transcends the individuals who are there at any one moment. The monastery itself is apparently centuries old, and the cells have been inhabited by generation after generation of monks, so the wood of the floors has that marvelous, lived-in look of worn-down paths where the monks have walked day after day for decades and centuries. Such a thing reminds me that, more than having lives, we are instantiations of Life, members of a pattern that is lived out in us, and it takes a place that old to remind us that we are part of something that was here long before us and will be around long after we are dust. Coming out of the theater was quite a shock, both getting back into the noise of people and highway, but even the next day at the student mass at SLU: beautiful (in a totally different way), but the film drew out how loud even such a well-done mass can be. As much as I talk about silence and enjoy having stretches of silence during my day, and coming home to a quiet house at night, I found the movie challenging because it was so quiet, and so long; I admit I found myself looking at my watch a couple of times, even though I really didn’t want it to be over. Perhaps that was the subtle prophetic message of a film of this kind: we are deliberately making a long, slow movie, we are deliberately going to linger on places and faces longer than you are comfortable with, to make you a little uncomfortable so hopefully you actually look at what you see.
On another topic, I found out about a month ago that Fr. Steve Duffy, my academic mentor from my days as an undergraduate, passed away. I have come back and back to what it means, and I still can’t figure out quite what to say. Duffy continued to be a mentor for me long after I left Loyola; I went to see him just about every time I came back into town, and I would listen to the same stories I had heard the previous time, and I loved them just as much knowing how they were going to end. It’s not exactly that I am numb with mourning – he meant a lot to me, and I regret that we will never get together for dinner and good wine again, but it simply is what it is. He lived well, the way he wanted to, and he never felt the need to play by other people’s rules, and I suspect he died with his boots on, without making a fuss about dying (he never even told me he had cancer or that he was dying – I wonder when he found out). No philosophizing about “not taking things for granted” or “carpe diem” or anything like that – I simply close by remembering a great man. Here’s to you, Duffy.
On another topic, I found out about a month ago that Fr. Steve Duffy, my academic mentor from my days as an undergraduate, passed away. I have come back and back to what it means, and I still can’t figure out quite what to say. Duffy continued to be a mentor for me long after I left Loyola; I went to see him just about every time I came back into town, and I would listen to the same stories I had heard the previous time, and I loved them just as much knowing how they were going to end. It’s not exactly that I am numb with mourning – he meant a lot to me, and I regret that we will never get together for dinner and good wine again, but it simply is what it is. He lived well, the way he wanted to, and he never felt the need to play by other people’s rules, and I suspect he died with his boots on, without making a fuss about dying (he never even told me he had cancer or that he was dying – I wonder when he found out). No philosophizing about “not taking things for granted” or “carpe diem” or anything like that – I simply close by remembering a great man. Here’s to you, Duffy.
Monday, April 2, 2007
OK, everyone, here's a long post. I wanted to just include a link you could click if you wanted to download it, but I can't figure out how to do that on this thing. If you know, please let me know and I'll post it that way. This is the paper I gave at the SLU Graduate Research Symposium and the Notre Dame Peace Studies Conference. It needs more work, particularly dealing with how Richard Horsley modifies Camara's framework of the spiral of violence.
“Psychic numbing, dehumanization and the spiral of violence”
Br. Patrick Cousins, SC
St. Louis University
In this paper I intend to explore dehumanization of the Other, primarily through linguistic means, and what psychiatrist Robert Jay Lifton calls “psychic numbing” as a primary means of alleviating the guilt of violent action. In particular, I will examine Dom Helder Camara’s notion of the “spiral of violence” and how it plays out at a psychological level as a series of movements of dehumanizations and victimizations. I will examine briefly the notion of the Other as monster or subhuman, concluding with a reassessment of the theological virtue of hope as a primary means of rehumanizing the Other and enabling the cessation of the cycle of violence.
Dom Helder Camara, the late Archbishop of Recife, Brazil, used the term “spiral of violence” to name the following pattern: violence in the form of oppression or injustice tends to prompt a violent response from those who are oppressed, which leads the initiating party to respond with greater force, creating a self-sustaining, escalating progression of violence and counterviolence. Even when one side wins and the conflict appears to have been resolved, typically the winning party is free to impose its will upon the loser, initiating the spiral anew. (Windley-Daoust 290) While upholding the correctness of this image, I would argue that what is happening can be understood as the logical result of a spiral of victimization and dehumanization, which goes on at the individual and communal levels.
In the model of the spiral of violence, the group suffering the latest injustice, seeing themselves as human beings with rights and dignity, feels victimized because the opposing side has brutishly attacked them. Since the victims presumably see themselves as “peace-loving” people who are only doing what they must to defend themselves, the Other must be a true monster, in which case the only appropriate response is absolute destruction. In fact, NOT to destroy the Other is not only cowardly but dangerous, since it places the innocent at risk. Psychiatrist Robert Jay Lifton puts it this way: “Where the threat is so absolute and so ultimate – where the struggle becomes ‘fighting between humans and subhumans,’ in Himmler’s phrase – genocide becomes not only appropriate but an urgent necessity.” (Doctors 477)
Convinced that violence is the only way to respond to the seemingly conscienceless foe, the victim, or rather the side which feels victimized by the latest attack, now strikes back, not out of vengeance, they say, but out of obligation to the innocent of the world to stop this subhuman foe. Thomas Merton uses the Vietnam War as an example of this phenomenon: “The jungles are thought to be ‘infested’ with Communists, and hence one goes after them as one would go after ants in the kitchen back home. And in this process of ‘cleaning up’ (the language of ‘cleansing’ appeases and pacifies the conscience) one becomes without realizing it a murderer of women and children.” (Merton 253) The Other, who has now become the recipient of the aforementioned counterattack, easily realizes that the enemy has become a murderer of women and children and feels victimized by the savage attack of the enemy, who must be without conscience, hence a monster, and the cycle continues. Each side’s latest act of what they would see as self-defense looks like inhumanity to the Other, convincing the Other even more of the monstrosity of their enemy and lengthening the laundry list of reasons why they are justified in using torture, mass killings, and terrorism to destroy the enemy.
It seems obvious that the death of even legitimate combatants in war, whether soldiers or insurgents, provokes renewed hostility and demands for vengeance by their communities, since they almost universally see their fallen loved ones as heroes and martyrs who have fallen for a noble cause. If this is in fact the case, even so-called “legitimate” deaths will continue the spiral of violence as newer recruits are motivated by the memory of their fallen allies not to allow the enemy to continue their evil ways. Each side believes that sufficient force will break the will of the Other; paradoxically, however, each side’s resolve to endure, to never surrender, is typically strengthened by each attack to which they are subjected.
To carry on with the dehumanization of the Other, however, it is essential to avoid anything that would rehumanize the Other and thereby introduce guilt or compassion. In his magisterial psychiatric study The Nazi Doctors, Lifton coins the term “psychic numbing” to refer to means by which the perpetrator of an act of inhumanity is able to avoid experiencing psychologically what he or she is doing. (Doctors 442) In particular, he claims that the bureaucratization and technologization of violence have become the most effective means of psychic numbing. Psychologist Dave Grossman goes so far as to view the history of warfare as “a series of progressively more effective ways to enable combatants to overcome the inherent psychological resistance to killing.” (MacNair 5)
Speaking about bureaucratization, Lifton says, “bureaucracy deamplifies genocide…Central to this process is the dampening of language, the use not only of euphemisms (‘resettlement’ or ‘deportation’ for killing) but also of certain code terms (‘special treatment,’ for instance) that are specific enough in designating murderous acts to maintain bureaucratic efficiency, even to give them special priority, while contributing to a partial sense that one is not murdering people at all but doing something benign.” (Doctors 495) Following World War II, for example, Germans coined the term Schreibtischtäter or “desk criminal” to refer to who gave orders to others to do the dirty work while avoiding feeling that they were themselves guilty of anything (Doctors 60), while those lower in the chain of command could make what is called an “agentic shift,” which moves the individual to “feel responsible to authority rather than for actions.” (MacNair 11) In this kind of framework, the morality of an action is based on such standards as loyalty, obedience, and love for one’s own group, rather than on standards such as justice, compassion or acknowledgement of human dignity.
In his classic anti-poem, “Chant to be Used in Processions Around a Site with Furnaces,” Thomas Merton speaks in the voice of the “efficient” concentration camp commandant who “made improvements” and “remained decent,” pointing up his ability to completely isolate such presumably noble ideals as “efficiency” from the horrific contexts in which they occur. He closes with the line, “Do not think yourself better because you burn up friends and enemies with long-range missiles without ever seeing what you have done,” (Merton 262) a reference to the Vietnam War which echoes Lifton’s own discoveries he made while working with Vietnam veterans, namely, that there is an inverse relationship between the psychic distance from the Other and the level of psychotic problems that emerge upon killing the Other. The bombardier, for example, was able to calculate the effects of his work in terms of technical skill, since there were no faces to connect with the deed done, while the general infantryman in general faced much more psychic trauma as a result of seeing the person whom he killed. (Home 349)
In fact, it is for that same reason that Nazi leaders transitioned from face-to-face killing of Jews by Einsatzgruppen troops to more numbed or distanced means such as the use of Zyklon B to poison them (Doctors 15). Lifton writes about, “a technician involved in bomb preparation [in Vietnam] who later came to oppose the war but, when accused of having been a war criminal, answered simply: ‘I don’t feel like a war criminal. What I was doing is just like screwing fuses into sockets.’…Here is the essence of numbed warfare: killing with a near-total separation of act from idea…avoidance of guilt is built into the technology.” (Home 347)
Even at this numbed distance, euphemism and officialspeak continue to suck the meaning out of a reality: Merton points out that in Auschwitz, for example, the poison gas Zyklon B was referred to as “disinfectants” and “materials for resettlement of Jews.” (Merton 155) Similarly, Lifton says about the Vietnam war, “The various names chosen for the systems and component devices – Sensors, Gravel, Grasshopper, Walleye, Black Crow, Comfy Bee, Puff the Magic Dragon – serve to domesticate them by means of an aberrant mixture of humor and play. They lend an Orwellian character of words meaning their opposites (war is peace), since ‘Generally, the more innocuous the code name, the more deadly the weapon.’” (Home 353)
How, then, to respond to such a numbed and numbing world? In a word: hope. A genuine commitment to nonviolence demands a renewed understanding of the theological virtue of hope, less as waiting for the realization of a set of distant eschatological doctrines, and more as an acknowledgement that God can do more than we are able of accomplishing. The Other in fact does have more conscience than he or she manifests and does in fact have the potential to be converted. Walter Wink puts it this way: “The enemy too believes he or she is in the right, and fears us, because we represent a threat against his or her values, lifestyle, or affluence. When we demonize our enemies, calling them names and identifying then with absolute evil, we deny that they have that of God within them that makes transformation possible.” (Wink 59) An anthropology which lacks that sense of hope in people’s potential to be converted has little hope of avoiding a purely pragmatic morality; if we must accomplish on our own everything that we want to see happen, then we must force the other into submission by any means necessary, because no one else is going to stop them but us. After white racists bombed a church in Birmingham in 1963, killing four adolescent girls, Martin Luther King preached their eulogy, including the following lines (which lost him many supporters for not calling for violence against whites, who had seemingly proved that they didn’t understand anything but force): “We must not become bitter; nor must we harbor the desire to retaliate with violence. We must not lose faith in our white brothers. Somehow we must believe that the most misguided among them can learn to respect the dignity and worth of all human personality.” (King 222) That is, although it is hard at this moment to see the possibility of conversion in those who would do this, hope is our only means of warding off the dehumanizing despair that would demand that, for the sake of our innocents, we must crush those who would crush us.
I would argue that hand in hand with this depth of hope is a renewed theology and sociology of suffering as a primary means of conversion. Modern theology has (rightly) worked so hard to undo the damage done by passivist (as opposed to pacifist) notions of “offering up” sufferings for the sake of spiritual merit that there is often little room left in our modern consciousness for a fair evaluation of Martin King’s oft-repeated statement that “unmerited suffering is redemptive.” (King 221) It seems only realistic that the potential of the Other to be converted by violence, that is, by inflicting suffering on them, is virtually nil; violence, even used justly, can, at best, block the ability of the aggressor to carry on with continued aggression. Rather, the Other has a much more realistic possibility of being converted by those who have the courage and the terrible detachment from self to absorb suffering without striking back, who can actively face suffering without becoming either victims or victimizers, who refuse to dehumanize the Other and thereby continue the spiral of violence. When the aggressor no longer feels threatened or victimized, to strike out against the unarmed, obviously innocent Other can not be psychically justified; the aggressor who expects violence from an Other whom he or she sees as monstrous has the possibility of confronting their own subhuman actions when they are carried out against people who pose them no threat.
At the same time, we must be sober about the reality of human sin and our capacity for evil (cf. Challenge #56), which should both keep us realistic about the Other and call us back to awareness of the depths of our OWN capacity for violence. We spend a lot of energy on creating and sustaining means of psychic numbing and dehumanization, and so it takes a lot of energy to break through and rehumanize the Other. Lifton recounts speaking with a friend about his interviews with former Nazis, and telling the friend that “they were by no means the demonic figures – sadistic, fanatic, lusting to kill – people have often thought them to be,” to which his friend replied, “But it is demonic that they were not demonic.” (Doctors 45) Discussing a Nazi stationed at Auschwitz who was infamous for his ruthless use of a torture device which bore his name (the “Boger swing”), Thomas Merton writes, “Not even Boger can be regarded without qualification as a monster. Auschwitz becomes a little more horrible when we have to admit that Boger too is a human being.” (Merton 157) As long as one group can convince themselves of the subhumanity and absolute evil of the Other, Merton says, “we have no need of monsters: ordinary policemen and good citizens will take care of everything.” (Merton 159) Only when we recall that they are ordinary people, good citizens, responding to threats like we do, do we have a chance of believing that they can change from a path of violence.
Works Cited
Camara, Helder. Spiral of Violence. Denville, NJ: Dimension Books. 1971.
King, Martin Luther. A Testament of Hope: The Essential Writings and Speeches of Martin
Luther King, Jr. Ed. James Melvin Washington. San Francisco: Harper. 1986.
Lifton, Robert Jay. Home From the War: Vietnam Veterans: Neither Victims nor Executioners.
New York: Simon and Schuster. 1973.
---. The Nazi Doctors: Medical Killing and the Psychology of Genocide. New York: Basic
Books. 1986.
Merton, Thomas. The Nonviolent Alternative. New York: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux. 1971.
U.S. Catholic Bishops. “The Challenge of Peace: God’s Promise and Our Response.” Catholic
Social Thought: The Documentary Heritage. Eds. David J. O’Brien and Thomas A.
Shannon. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis, 1992.
Windley-Daoust, Jerry, et. al. Living Justice and Peace. Winona, MN: Saint Mary’s Press,
2002.
Wink, Walter. Jesus and Nonviolence: A Third Way. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2003.
Mercy within mercy within mercy...
“Psychic numbing, dehumanization and the spiral of violence”
Br. Patrick Cousins, SC
St. Louis University
In this paper I intend to explore dehumanization of the Other, primarily through linguistic means, and what psychiatrist Robert Jay Lifton calls “psychic numbing” as a primary means of alleviating the guilt of violent action. In particular, I will examine Dom Helder Camara’s notion of the “spiral of violence” and how it plays out at a psychological level as a series of movements of dehumanizations and victimizations. I will examine briefly the notion of the Other as monster or subhuman, concluding with a reassessment of the theological virtue of hope as a primary means of rehumanizing the Other and enabling the cessation of the cycle of violence.
Dom Helder Camara, the late Archbishop of Recife, Brazil, used the term “spiral of violence” to name the following pattern: violence in the form of oppression or injustice tends to prompt a violent response from those who are oppressed, which leads the initiating party to respond with greater force, creating a self-sustaining, escalating progression of violence and counterviolence. Even when one side wins and the conflict appears to have been resolved, typically the winning party is free to impose its will upon the loser, initiating the spiral anew. (Windley-Daoust 290) While upholding the correctness of this image, I would argue that what is happening can be understood as the logical result of a spiral of victimization and dehumanization, which goes on at the individual and communal levels.
In the model of the spiral of violence, the group suffering the latest injustice, seeing themselves as human beings with rights and dignity, feels victimized because the opposing side has brutishly attacked them. Since the victims presumably see themselves as “peace-loving” people who are only doing what they must to defend themselves, the Other must be a true monster, in which case the only appropriate response is absolute destruction. In fact, NOT to destroy the Other is not only cowardly but dangerous, since it places the innocent at risk. Psychiatrist Robert Jay Lifton puts it this way: “Where the threat is so absolute and so ultimate – where the struggle becomes ‘fighting between humans and subhumans,’ in Himmler’s phrase – genocide becomes not only appropriate but an urgent necessity.” (Doctors 477)
Convinced that violence is the only way to respond to the seemingly conscienceless foe, the victim, or rather the side which feels victimized by the latest attack, now strikes back, not out of vengeance, they say, but out of obligation to the innocent of the world to stop this subhuman foe. Thomas Merton uses the Vietnam War as an example of this phenomenon: “The jungles are thought to be ‘infested’ with Communists, and hence one goes after them as one would go after ants in the kitchen back home. And in this process of ‘cleaning up’ (the language of ‘cleansing’ appeases and pacifies the conscience) one becomes without realizing it a murderer of women and children.” (Merton 253) The Other, who has now become the recipient of the aforementioned counterattack, easily realizes that the enemy has become a murderer of women and children and feels victimized by the savage attack of the enemy, who must be without conscience, hence a monster, and the cycle continues. Each side’s latest act of what they would see as self-defense looks like inhumanity to the Other, convincing the Other even more of the monstrosity of their enemy and lengthening the laundry list of reasons why they are justified in using torture, mass killings, and terrorism to destroy the enemy.
It seems obvious that the death of even legitimate combatants in war, whether soldiers or insurgents, provokes renewed hostility and demands for vengeance by their communities, since they almost universally see their fallen loved ones as heroes and martyrs who have fallen for a noble cause. If this is in fact the case, even so-called “legitimate” deaths will continue the spiral of violence as newer recruits are motivated by the memory of their fallen allies not to allow the enemy to continue their evil ways. Each side believes that sufficient force will break the will of the Other; paradoxically, however, each side’s resolve to endure, to never surrender, is typically strengthened by each attack to which they are subjected.
To carry on with the dehumanization of the Other, however, it is essential to avoid anything that would rehumanize the Other and thereby introduce guilt or compassion. In his magisterial psychiatric study The Nazi Doctors, Lifton coins the term “psychic numbing” to refer to means by which the perpetrator of an act of inhumanity is able to avoid experiencing psychologically what he or she is doing. (Doctors 442) In particular, he claims that the bureaucratization and technologization of violence have become the most effective means of psychic numbing. Psychologist Dave Grossman goes so far as to view the history of warfare as “a series of progressively more effective ways to enable combatants to overcome the inherent psychological resistance to killing.” (MacNair 5)
Speaking about bureaucratization, Lifton says, “bureaucracy deamplifies genocide…Central to this process is the dampening of language, the use not only of euphemisms (‘resettlement’ or ‘deportation’ for killing) but also of certain code terms (‘special treatment,’ for instance) that are specific enough in designating murderous acts to maintain bureaucratic efficiency, even to give them special priority, while contributing to a partial sense that one is not murdering people at all but doing something benign.” (Doctors 495) Following World War II, for example, Germans coined the term Schreibtischtäter or “desk criminal” to refer to who gave orders to others to do the dirty work while avoiding feeling that they were themselves guilty of anything (Doctors 60), while those lower in the chain of command could make what is called an “agentic shift,” which moves the individual to “feel responsible to authority rather than for actions.” (MacNair 11) In this kind of framework, the morality of an action is based on such standards as loyalty, obedience, and love for one’s own group, rather than on standards such as justice, compassion or acknowledgement of human dignity.
In his classic anti-poem, “Chant to be Used in Processions Around a Site with Furnaces,” Thomas Merton speaks in the voice of the “efficient” concentration camp commandant who “made improvements” and “remained decent,” pointing up his ability to completely isolate such presumably noble ideals as “efficiency” from the horrific contexts in which they occur. He closes with the line, “Do not think yourself better because you burn up friends and enemies with long-range missiles without ever seeing what you have done,” (Merton 262) a reference to the Vietnam War which echoes Lifton’s own discoveries he made while working with Vietnam veterans, namely, that there is an inverse relationship between the psychic distance from the Other and the level of psychotic problems that emerge upon killing the Other. The bombardier, for example, was able to calculate the effects of his work in terms of technical skill, since there were no faces to connect with the deed done, while the general infantryman in general faced much more psychic trauma as a result of seeing the person whom he killed. (Home 349)
In fact, it is for that same reason that Nazi leaders transitioned from face-to-face killing of Jews by Einsatzgruppen troops to more numbed or distanced means such as the use of Zyklon B to poison them (Doctors 15). Lifton writes about, “a technician involved in bomb preparation [in Vietnam] who later came to oppose the war but, when accused of having been a war criminal, answered simply: ‘I don’t feel like a war criminal. What I was doing is just like screwing fuses into sockets.’…Here is the essence of numbed warfare: killing with a near-total separation of act from idea…avoidance of guilt is built into the technology.” (Home 347)
Even at this numbed distance, euphemism and officialspeak continue to suck the meaning out of a reality: Merton points out that in Auschwitz, for example, the poison gas Zyklon B was referred to as “disinfectants” and “materials for resettlement of Jews.” (Merton 155) Similarly, Lifton says about the Vietnam war, “The various names chosen for the systems and component devices – Sensors, Gravel, Grasshopper, Walleye, Black Crow, Comfy Bee, Puff the Magic Dragon – serve to domesticate them by means of an aberrant mixture of humor and play. They lend an Orwellian character of words meaning their opposites (war is peace), since ‘Generally, the more innocuous the code name, the more deadly the weapon.’” (Home 353)
How, then, to respond to such a numbed and numbing world? In a word: hope. A genuine commitment to nonviolence demands a renewed understanding of the theological virtue of hope, less as waiting for the realization of a set of distant eschatological doctrines, and more as an acknowledgement that God can do more than we are able of accomplishing. The Other in fact does have more conscience than he or she manifests and does in fact have the potential to be converted. Walter Wink puts it this way: “The enemy too believes he or she is in the right, and fears us, because we represent a threat against his or her values, lifestyle, or affluence. When we demonize our enemies, calling them names and identifying then with absolute evil, we deny that they have that of God within them that makes transformation possible.” (Wink 59) An anthropology which lacks that sense of hope in people’s potential to be converted has little hope of avoiding a purely pragmatic morality; if we must accomplish on our own everything that we want to see happen, then we must force the other into submission by any means necessary, because no one else is going to stop them but us. After white racists bombed a church in Birmingham in 1963, killing four adolescent girls, Martin Luther King preached their eulogy, including the following lines (which lost him many supporters for not calling for violence against whites, who had seemingly proved that they didn’t understand anything but force): “We must not become bitter; nor must we harbor the desire to retaliate with violence. We must not lose faith in our white brothers. Somehow we must believe that the most misguided among them can learn to respect the dignity and worth of all human personality.” (King 222) That is, although it is hard at this moment to see the possibility of conversion in those who would do this, hope is our only means of warding off the dehumanizing despair that would demand that, for the sake of our innocents, we must crush those who would crush us.
I would argue that hand in hand with this depth of hope is a renewed theology and sociology of suffering as a primary means of conversion. Modern theology has (rightly) worked so hard to undo the damage done by passivist (as opposed to pacifist) notions of “offering up” sufferings for the sake of spiritual merit that there is often little room left in our modern consciousness for a fair evaluation of Martin King’s oft-repeated statement that “unmerited suffering is redemptive.” (King 221) It seems only realistic that the potential of the Other to be converted by violence, that is, by inflicting suffering on them, is virtually nil; violence, even used justly, can, at best, block the ability of the aggressor to carry on with continued aggression. Rather, the Other has a much more realistic possibility of being converted by those who have the courage and the terrible detachment from self to absorb suffering without striking back, who can actively face suffering without becoming either victims or victimizers, who refuse to dehumanize the Other and thereby continue the spiral of violence. When the aggressor no longer feels threatened or victimized, to strike out against the unarmed, obviously innocent Other can not be psychically justified; the aggressor who expects violence from an Other whom he or she sees as monstrous has the possibility of confronting their own subhuman actions when they are carried out against people who pose them no threat.
At the same time, we must be sober about the reality of human sin and our capacity for evil (cf. Challenge #56), which should both keep us realistic about the Other and call us back to awareness of the depths of our OWN capacity for violence. We spend a lot of energy on creating and sustaining means of psychic numbing and dehumanization, and so it takes a lot of energy to break through and rehumanize the Other. Lifton recounts speaking with a friend about his interviews with former Nazis, and telling the friend that “they were by no means the demonic figures – sadistic, fanatic, lusting to kill – people have often thought them to be,” to which his friend replied, “But it is demonic that they were not demonic.” (Doctors 45) Discussing a Nazi stationed at Auschwitz who was infamous for his ruthless use of a torture device which bore his name (the “Boger swing”), Thomas Merton writes, “Not even Boger can be regarded without qualification as a monster. Auschwitz becomes a little more horrible when we have to admit that Boger too is a human being.” (Merton 157) As long as one group can convince themselves of the subhumanity and absolute evil of the Other, Merton says, “we have no need of monsters: ordinary policemen and good citizens will take care of everything.” (Merton 159) Only when we recall that they are ordinary people, good citizens, responding to threats like we do, do we have a chance of believing that they can change from a path of violence.
Works Cited
Camara, Helder. Spiral of Violence. Denville, NJ: Dimension Books. 1971.
King, Martin Luther. A Testament of Hope: The Essential Writings and Speeches of Martin
Luther King, Jr. Ed. James Melvin Washington. San Francisco: Harper. 1986.
Lifton, Robert Jay. Home From the War: Vietnam Veterans: Neither Victims nor Executioners.
New York: Simon and Schuster. 1973.
---. The Nazi Doctors: Medical Killing and the Psychology of Genocide. New York: Basic
Books. 1986.
Merton, Thomas. The Nonviolent Alternative. New York: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux. 1971.
U.S. Catholic Bishops. “The Challenge of Peace: God’s Promise and Our Response.” Catholic
Social Thought: The Documentary Heritage. Eds. David J. O’Brien and Thomas A.
Shannon. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis, 1992.
Windley-Daoust, Jerry, et. al. Living Justice and Peace. Winona, MN: Saint Mary’s Press,
2002.
Wink, Walter. Jesus and Nonviolence: A Third Way. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2003.
Mercy within mercy within mercy...
Tuesday, March 20, 2007
the Bronx...
Below is a letter I wrote after my spring break trip to the Bronx and sent to a few people who might have been interested...
Hi Everyone,
Well, this is a long overdue update, and so much has happened in the past week that just covering that would be a longer-than-usual email. Two weeks ago was midterm week, so the students were running all over the place. Monday night (5 March) I had the students in the service-learning community that I chaplain gather in one of the large meeting rooms in the student center, and we walked a fold-out labyrinth that campus ministry has. None of them had ever done one before, so it was a nice way to both introduce them to an ancient form of Christian prayer and to teach them a form of meditation that could help them de-stress during midterms. I took off from work Wednesday and Thursday, since I was going to be on the Spring Break trip all the next week and wouldn't have a "day off" for over a week. Friday morning my new credit card (finally) came in (the old one expired at the end of February), so after several days of sweating bullets and making increasingly desperate calls to Brenda in the province office, I spent the day running around making purchases that I needed for thetrip. Saturday morning we left for the Bronx, and the trip there was fairly uneventful apart from the usual shenanigans that happen when you cram 8 college students into two SUVs. Sunday we finished thetrip, but my van took an unexpected detour after the navigator failed to point out the exit we needed to take, so we had the adventure of driving through Manhattan to get to the Bronx - no easy feat, as you may know, during the middle of the day. After about an hour and a half of meandering around, we showed up and got the grand tour from the sister who directs the Highbridge Community Life Center. After church we decided to take our evening and go into town, since we wouldn't start work until the next morning, so we figured out the subway system and headed down to Grand Central Station, from which we walked to Times Square, which I can only describe in two words: sensory overload. We found a little local place to eat (I'll be damned if we would drive a thousand miles to eat at a place we could find just as easily in New Orleans or St. Louis!) and headed back to our "accommodations," which were not particularly accommodating: concrete floor, one working shower (no hot water, thank you very much), pipes making weird noises all night, and a couple of rodent neighbors to share the room with. We made do, of course, but I don't recommend it if you are looking for a luxury suite in the Bronx.
The next morning was wild: we walked around the neighborhood visiting all the different sites that Highbridge operates (about 6 different works) before doing a little work and coming back to our home base to participate in a neighborhood activity. It turns out that a couple of days before we got there, a big tenement fire had killed 8 or 9 children from an African family that had just immigrated to the U.S. -you may have seen something in the news - and that was right down the street from where we were staying. We went to the house that had caught fire, where there was a community memorial, and then we walked with a couple of hundred people a few miles into the Bronx to the mosque where the funeral was going to be. The police had closed the streets and laid out tarps for the Muslim community to come and do prayer there, but we were able to watch people pouring in from all over. We stayed about an hour, but we never saw any of the actual service, because we had to get back to work and because the service showed no signs of starting anytime soon. All the way back toHighbridge, we saw people walking towards the thing - I would not be surprised if 10,000 members of the Muslim community showed up for this funeral. That afternoon we worked with kids in the afterschool program that Highbridge runs. You all know me well enough to know that playing with 9-year-olds is not my favorite thing in the world, but it was actually fun - a little tutoring, a little playing with the kids, a little watching them slowly destroy my Frisbee by repeatedly pitching it into the wall. That night, a Lasallian volunteer invited us to the Brothers' house where she lives to eat and sleep over, which was a wonderful change from the previous night. Tuesday we went back to work at our sites, and I got to try my hand at teaching a little ESL. It was actually very challenging, esp. since they didn't want us to use any Spanish - how does one explain in English the words "outhouse" or "cellar" (it was in our reading) to a person who has a very limited grasp of English?
That night (Tuesday) we drove to Goshen, a town about an hour north where Highbridge runs an organic farm. The next two days we were there, and that was really the highlight of the trip for me. The farm manager put us to work on all kinds of manual labor projects, which were much more up my alley than the stuff with the little kids in theBronx. I got to work a chainsaw for a while (if you know me and chainsaws, you know I was in heaven), and then we did all kinds of work, from planting mushrooms and hauling compost to cutting lumber and building birdhouses. Our schedule there was perfect: a few hours of work after breakfast, a simple lunch of sandwiches, fruit, and maybe a cooked dish, an hour or so for a siesta or whatever, and a few more hours in the afternoon for work before dinner, which we all helped to prepare and clean up. In the evening, we had time to go shopping for groceries, watch a film, or just sit around and talk.
Friday morning we drove back to the Bronx (in the beginnings of what would become a serious snow storm) and took the subway back to Manhattan until midafternoon. We got to see the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the site of the World Trade Center before going back to Highbridge for a couple of hours of work with the students. Back to the Brothers' house that evening (I think they just took pity on us because of how rustic our original living conditions were!), and off for home the next morning. We got back about noon on Sunday, ate together, and split up. I did a few unpacking things yesterday, but I was absolutely beat, so I spent much of today cleaning up the mess that was my office. All in all, a marvelous trip, a few stressful moments (mostly related to navigating in the chaos that is New YorkCity) notwithstanding.
Nothing too big is going this week - the usual round of meetings and office work, but next week is the trip to Notre Dame for that PeaceStudies Conference, so I need to finish preparing my paper ("Language, dehumanization and the spiral of violence") and work on my syllabus for the course I'm teaching in the fall (on Thomas Merton, for those of you I haven't emailed in a while). Oh, on that note, the chair of the theo. department bumped into me a couple of weeks ago and mentioned that they have a course on prayer on the books that no one has taught in a couple of years, so would I perhaps think about teaching it in the spring? How on earth do you say no to something like that? That's about it for now, so I hope this letter finds you well, and more to come soon. Let me know how you are all doing when you get a chance.
Yours,
Patrick
Mercy within mercy within mercy...
Hi Everyone,
Well, this is a long overdue update, and so much has happened in the past week that just covering that would be a longer-than-usual email. Two weeks ago was midterm week, so the students were running all over the place. Monday night (5 March) I had the students in the service-learning community that I chaplain gather in one of the large meeting rooms in the student center, and we walked a fold-out labyrinth that campus ministry has. None of them had ever done one before, so it was a nice way to both introduce them to an ancient form of Christian prayer and to teach them a form of meditation that could help them de-stress during midterms. I took off from work Wednesday and Thursday, since I was going to be on the Spring Break trip all the next week and wouldn't have a "day off" for over a week. Friday morning my new credit card (finally) came in (the old one expired at the end of February), so after several days of sweating bullets and making increasingly desperate calls to Brenda in the province office, I spent the day running around making purchases that I needed for thetrip. Saturday morning we left for the Bronx, and the trip there was fairly uneventful apart from the usual shenanigans that happen when you cram 8 college students into two SUVs. Sunday we finished thetrip, but my van took an unexpected detour after the navigator failed to point out the exit we needed to take, so we had the adventure of driving through Manhattan to get to the Bronx - no easy feat, as you may know, during the middle of the day. After about an hour and a half of meandering around, we showed up and got the grand tour from the sister who directs the Highbridge Community Life Center. After church we decided to take our evening and go into town, since we wouldn't start work until the next morning, so we figured out the subway system and headed down to Grand Central Station, from which we walked to Times Square, which I can only describe in two words: sensory overload. We found a little local place to eat (I'll be damned if we would drive a thousand miles to eat at a place we could find just as easily in New Orleans or St. Louis!) and headed back to our "accommodations," which were not particularly accommodating: concrete floor, one working shower (no hot water, thank you very much), pipes making weird noises all night, and a couple of rodent neighbors to share the room with. We made do, of course, but I don't recommend it if you are looking for a luxury suite in the Bronx.
The next morning was wild: we walked around the neighborhood visiting all the different sites that Highbridge operates (about 6 different works) before doing a little work and coming back to our home base to participate in a neighborhood activity. It turns out that a couple of days before we got there, a big tenement fire had killed 8 or 9 children from an African family that had just immigrated to the U.S. -you may have seen something in the news - and that was right down the street from where we were staying. We went to the house that had caught fire, where there was a community memorial, and then we walked with a couple of hundred people a few miles into the Bronx to the mosque where the funeral was going to be. The police had closed the streets and laid out tarps for the Muslim community to come and do prayer there, but we were able to watch people pouring in from all over. We stayed about an hour, but we never saw any of the actual service, because we had to get back to work and because the service showed no signs of starting anytime soon. All the way back toHighbridge, we saw people walking towards the thing - I would not be surprised if 10,000 members of the Muslim community showed up for this funeral. That afternoon we worked with kids in the afterschool program that Highbridge runs. You all know me well enough to know that playing with 9-year-olds is not my favorite thing in the world, but it was actually fun - a little tutoring, a little playing with the kids, a little watching them slowly destroy my Frisbee by repeatedly pitching it into the wall. That night, a Lasallian volunteer invited us to the Brothers' house where she lives to eat and sleep over, which was a wonderful change from the previous night. Tuesday we went back to work at our sites, and I got to try my hand at teaching a little ESL. It was actually very challenging, esp. since they didn't want us to use any Spanish - how does one explain in English the words "outhouse" or "cellar" (it was in our reading) to a person who has a very limited grasp of English?
That night (Tuesday) we drove to Goshen, a town about an hour north where Highbridge runs an organic farm. The next two days we were there, and that was really the highlight of the trip for me. The farm manager put us to work on all kinds of manual labor projects, which were much more up my alley than the stuff with the little kids in theBronx. I got to work a chainsaw for a while (if you know me and chainsaws, you know I was in heaven), and then we did all kinds of work, from planting mushrooms and hauling compost to cutting lumber and building birdhouses. Our schedule there was perfect: a few hours of work after breakfast, a simple lunch of sandwiches, fruit, and maybe a cooked dish, an hour or so for a siesta or whatever, and a few more hours in the afternoon for work before dinner, which we all helped to prepare and clean up. In the evening, we had time to go shopping for groceries, watch a film, or just sit around and talk.
Friday morning we drove back to the Bronx (in the beginnings of what would become a serious snow storm) and took the subway back to Manhattan until midafternoon. We got to see the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the site of the World Trade Center before going back to Highbridge for a couple of hours of work with the students. Back to the Brothers' house that evening (I think they just took pity on us because of how rustic our original living conditions were!), and off for home the next morning. We got back about noon on Sunday, ate together, and split up. I did a few unpacking things yesterday, but I was absolutely beat, so I spent much of today cleaning up the mess that was my office. All in all, a marvelous trip, a few stressful moments (mostly related to navigating in the chaos that is New YorkCity) notwithstanding.
Nothing too big is going this week - the usual round of meetings and office work, but next week is the trip to Notre Dame for that PeaceStudies Conference, so I need to finish preparing my paper ("Language, dehumanization and the spiral of violence") and work on my syllabus for the course I'm teaching in the fall (on Thomas Merton, for those of you I haven't emailed in a while). Oh, on that note, the chair of the theo. department bumped into me a couple of weeks ago and mentioned that they have a course on prayer on the books that no one has taught in a couple of years, so would I perhaps think about teaching it in the spring? How on earth do you say no to something like that? That's about it for now, so I hope this letter finds you well, and more to come soon. Let me know how you are all doing when you get a chance.
Yours,
Patrick
Mercy within mercy within mercy...
Friday, March 9, 2007
Who knows what evil lurks...?
My credit card expired last week, at the end of February, so I called my province secretary in New Orleans to ask about getting the new one. She said that she assumed I would get it in a day or so, but by Monday (March 5), still no card. I called again, a little more urgently, because I’m leading a spring break trip to the Bronx this weekend, and I REALLY need a credit card to do it. She called them, raised a little hell, and called me back: they’re Express Mailing it to me, she says, and they SWEAR it will be there Wednesday. Wednesday comes, no card, so I call again. OK, they’re mailing a second card out, so one or the other should reach you soon, but it might be Saturday. No, I’m leaving Saturday, I say, even more urgently than last time, and I really need that card. Well, you need to be there to sign for it, so be at home and it should come today (Thursday). You guessed it – not only did I not get my card, but I also wasted a day that I should have spent preparing for the trip, because I was at home waiting for this *$@&! card that never came. “More tortuous than all else is the human heart, beyond remedy; who can understand it?” (Jer 17:9) In the reading for today’s mass (8 March 2007), Jeremiah knows well the illusions and falsehoods that we create around ourselves to convince ourselves that we are holy, that we are peaceful or whatever it is that we seek to be. I see in this the old saying, “There, but for the grace of God, go I.” As much as I read and write about nonviolence and reconciliation and so on, I got angrier today than I have been in a long time, all over something stupid like not getting a credit card. What might be hiding within me that could be brought out by something REALLY bad – real injustice, true atrocity, not just getting lost in the cracks of a big corporation’s system?
The gospel for today was the story of Lazarus and the rich man (LK 16:19-31). Appropriate considering that I am getting ready to accompany 9 students on a trip to the Bronx to work with homeless people. The rich man walked over Lazarus every day to get onto his property and chose to make him invisible. How many homeless people in St. Louis or New Orleans or Baton Rouge did I choose to ignore? Why does it seem that we (ok, I) need a special event and a thousand-mile drive to pay attention to homeless people? How much energy would we really have to expend here at home to find homeless people, or better, how much energy do we have to expend to consciously avoid seeing them? It is great to go to the Bronx or wherever to be with people for spring break, but maybe it would be even more important for us to come back with a new vision of the needs of people here, that we don’t need to drive a thousand miles to notice poor people. Abraham warns the rich man that if his family would not listen to Moses and the prophets (i.e. the Old Testament, the tradition of the people) they won’t listen even if someone returns from the dead. For us who DO have someone who has returned from death, will the message sink in?
The gospel for today was the story of Lazarus and the rich man (LK 16:19-31). Appropriate considering that I am getting ready to accompany 9 students on a trip to the Bronx to work with homeless people. The rich man walked over Lazarus every day to get onto his property and chose to make him invisible. How many homeless people in St. Louis or New Orleans or Baton Rouge did I choose to ignore? Why does it seem that we (ok, I) need a special event and a thousand-mile drive to pay attention to homeless people? How much energy would we really have to expend here at home to find homeless people, or better, how much energy do we have to expend to consciously avoid seeing them? It is great to go to the Bronx or wherever to be with people for spring break, but maybe it would be even more important for us to come back with a new vision of the needs of people here, that we don’t need to drive a thousand miles to notice poor people. Abraham warns the rich man that if his family would not listen to Moses and the prophets (i.e. the Old Testament, the tradition of the people) they won’t listen even if someone returns from the dead. For us who DO have someone who has returned from death, will the message sink in?
Friday, March 2, 2007
Last night I gave a lecture on Thomas Merton as part of a lecture series that campus ministry offers. It went fine, I think, and after another campus minister said, "It was cool to see you in teacher mode." Her comment made me reflect on how much I do miss the classroom setting. As much as I delight in the kind of work I get to do in campus ministry, I am so excited that I will be able to teach a class in the fall, in particular since it is on Merton.
I had dinner this evening with a Jesuit theologian friend here at SLU. Most of his work has been in anthropology and issues concerning Native American religions. We went all over the place, but we kept coming back to enculturation and what it means to talk about the gospel living in cultures other than the European framework in which it has been nestled for so long. I mentioned a class I had taught to lay ministers, etc. while I was in Arizona, and discussing sacramental theology and the adage "grace builds on nature." What can we say about what happens theologically in, say, a sweatlodge or a pipe ceremony? The lodge in particular is so rich in symbol, has such a deep sense of liminal space, of transformation and rebirth and transition, that the grace it manifests is undeniable. That says nothing against the official sacraments, of course, but just like the Apologists drew on Platonism and Aquinas did theology through the lens of the "pagan" philosopher Aristotle, how might Christianity look through the lenses of the genuinely graced symbols and rituals of a Native American religion? I mentioned to my Dad yesterday on the phone that I love having the time in this job to do a little research and write a bit, but the problem is that, with so many brilliant people around, they all point me to books I should read and areas of research that I would love to pursue! As they say, you can do ANYTHING you want, but you can't do EVERYTHING you want.
Mercy within mercy within mercy...
I had dinner this evening with a Jesuit theologian friend here at SLU. Most of his work has been in anthropology and issues concerning Native American religions. We went all over the place, but we kept coming back to enculturation and what it means to talk about the gospel living in cultures other than the European framework in which it has been nestled for so long. I mentioned a class I had taught to lay ministers, etc. while I was in Arizona, and discussing sacramental theology and the adage "grace builds on nature." What can we say about what happens theologically in, say, a sweatlodge or a pipe ceremony? The lodge in particular is so rich in symbol, has such a deep sense of liminal space, of transformation and rebirth and transition, that the grace it manifests is undeniable. That says nothing against the official sacraments, of course, but just like the Apologists drew on Platonism and Aquinas did theology through the lens of the "pagan" philosopher Aristotle, how might Christianity look through the lenses of the genuinely graced symbols and rituals of a Native American religion? I mentioned to my Dad yesterday on the phone that I love having the time in this job to do a little research and write a bit, but the problem is that, with so many brilliant people around, they all point me to books I should read and areas of research that I would love to pursue! As they say, you can do ANYTHING you want, but you can't do EVERYTHING you want.
Mercy within mercy within mercy...
Sunday, February 25, 2007
"these people"
I wrote this a few months back, and I keep fiddling with it. It is based on a letter I read on the website for the Center for Theology and Social Analysis here in St. Louis. The letter, part of which I reproduce in the first paragraph, is by Barbara Lubin, who quotes Allen Ginsburg:
"F… hope,” he yelled. 'It’s not about hope…. You don’t do what you do because you hope things will get better. It’s about getting up every morning and asking yourself what’s the right thing to do and doing it.' Allen Ginsberg taught me a great lesson that night. He was right. It is wonderful if one is hopeful in life, but I will not wait around trying to feel hopeful about what is happening to the children in Palestine, Lebanon and Iraq, or in poor communities here in America. I will continue to be angry and I will get up every morning and ask myself 'What is the right thing to do?' and do it."
I think I understand what Lubin and Ginsberg mean, but hope isn’t mere optimism; it isn’t saying, “Maybe today people will just magically stop fighting.” Without hope that real transformation is possible, it seems to me there is little left but stopping the unredeemable adversary by any means necessary. That is, if we have no hope that those who kill children in Palestine, Lebanon, and Iraq can be brought to conversion by afflicting their consciences, how else can those children’s lives be spared than by crushing those who would (and do) crush them? Those who follow that path can easily find a justification, a reason why they have to torture or kill, just as President Bush was willing to sign a bill that functionally legalizes torture, and that justification would probably sound something like this: “These people don’t understand anything but force.”
Variations on that theme have held on every side of every major conflict and violent situation I have ever read anything about. Consider a few examples. From an advocate of manifest destiny: “The Indian…is an untamable, carnivorous animal.” From a Nazi doctor: “The annihilation of the Jews was a provision for the recovery of the world, and of Germany.” From the conflict in Vietnam: “The Pathet [Lao] and North Vietnamese are a plague. We have to eliminate them. They have no regard for human life.” From Malcolm X: “Don’t change the white man’s mind. You can’t change his mind, and that whole thing about appealing to the moral conscience of America – America’s conscience is bankrupt.” From the conflict in Israel and Palestine: “Arabs don't understand anything but force. So, it makes all the sense in the world to show them that we aren't afraid to use brute force against them. Only when we do this, will the world respect us, and America follow in our example.” From the tension with North Korea: “These barbarians in the east don't understand anything but FORCE.” From Osama Bin Laden: “Bush and Blair don't understand anything but the power of force. Every time they kill us, we kill them, so the balance of terror can be achieved.” From the Iraq war: “We may need to flatten Fallujah. We may need to destroy it. We may need to grind it, pulverize it and salt the soil, as the Romans did with troublesome enemies.” Also from the Iraq war: “The U.S. should blitzkrieg them with so much force that they realize that their cause is futile. For every one of ours that dies in a terrorist attack, we should kill a hundred of them, without worrying whether the dead were terrorists or innocent bystanders. You can't reason with these people; they don't understand anything but force.” From Donald Rumsfeld: “This is not an enemy that can be ignored, or negotiated with, or appeased.” That is, wiping them out is our only option.
Are all of those voices right? Are any of them? Are those whom we claim as the great moral leaders of human history totally inadequate to meeting the reality of terrorism? Far from it; on the contrary, many of them arose in situations akin to terrorism. Jesus, living under an often-brutal Roman occupation, surrounded by those who screamed for revolt, could still say, “I say to you, love your enemies, pray for those who persecute you, that you may be children of your heavenly Father, for he makes his sun rise on the bad and the good, and causes rain to fall on the just and the unjust. For is you love those who love you, what recompense will you have? Do not the tax collectors do the same? And if you greet your brothers only, what is unusual about that? Do not the pagans do the same?” Mohandas Gandhi, no stranger to the brutalization of his people, could still say, “Hatred can be overcome only by love. Counter-hatred only increases the surface as well as the depth of hatred.” Those who would dismiss such sentiments as pious and unrealistic should consider at once the deep-seated violence and racism he faced and the unparalleled measure of the success such pious sentiments achieved.
After white racists bombed a church in Birmingham, killing four adolescent girls, Martin Luther King preached their eulogy, including the following lines (which lost him many supporters for not calling for violence against whites, who had seemingly proved that they didn’t understand anything but force): “We must not become bitter; nor must we harbor the desire to retaliate with violence. We must not lose faith in our white brothers. Somehow we must believe that the most misguided among them can learn to respect the dignity and worth of all human personality.” That is, although it is hard at this moment to see the possibility of conversion in those who would do this, hope is our only means of warding off the despair that would demand that, for the sake of our innocents, we must crush those who would crush us. Similarly he could say, “To our most bitter opponents we say: ‘We shall match your capacity to inflict suffering by our capacity to endure suffering. We shall meet your physical force with soul force. Do to us what you will, and we shall continue to love you…Throw us in jail, and we shall still love you. Bomb our homes and threaten our children, and we shall still love you. Send your hooded perpetrators of violence into our community at the midnight hour and beat us and leave us half dead, and we shall still love you. But be ye assured that we will wear you down by our capacity to suffer. One day we shall win freedom, but not only for ourselves. We shall so appeal to your heart and conscience that we shall win you in the process, and our victory will be a double victory.’” Wouldn’t he have been justified in calling for vengeance? Don’t people have the right to defend themselves? Yes, but… But would that kind of backlash made them safer, would it have ended violence against blacks, would it have enabled even the very mixed record on race relations that this country currently has?
This is of enormous significance; each of them could have believed, easily and with justification, that they were up against enemies who understood nothing but force, but had they done so, history would have progressed very differently than it has. Before we repeat to ourselves that hope is not what we need now, or that the group at hand is beyond hope, that they are monsters who truly understand nothing but force, perhaps we can ask what it would mean to have the kind of Christian hope that makes possible the transformation of the enemy (and ourselves) through accepting suffering as opposed to inflicting it.
"F… hope,” he yelled. 'It’s not about hope…. You don’t do what you do because you hope things will get better. It’s about getting up every morning and asking yourself what’s the right thing to do and doing it.' Allen Ginsberg taught me a great lesson that night. He was right. It is wonderful if one is hopeful in life, but I will not wait around trying to feel hopeful about what is happening to the children in Palestine, Lebanon and Iraq, or in poor communities here in America. I will continue to be angry and I will get up every morning and ask myself 'What is the right thing to do?' and do it."
I think I understand what Lubin and Ginsberg mean, but hope isn’t mere optimism; it isn’t saying, “Maybe today people will just magically stop fighting.” Without hope that real transformation is possible, it seems to me there is little left but stopping the unredeemable adversary by any means necessary. That is, if we have no hope that those who kill children in Palestine, Lebanon, and Iraq can be brought to conversion by afflicting their consciences, how else can those children’s lives be spared than by crushing those who would (and do) crush them? Those who follow that path can easily find a justification, a reason why they have to torture or kill, just as President Bush was willing to sign a bill that functionally legalizes torture, and that justification would probably sound something like this: “These people don’t understand anything but force.”
Variations on that theme have held on every side of every major conflict and violent situation I have ever read anything about. Consider a few examples. From an advocate of manifest destiny: “The Indian…is an untamable, carnivorous animal.” From a Nazi doctor: “The annihilation of the Jews was a provision for the recovery of the world, and of Germany.” From the conflict in Vietnam: “The Pathet [Lao] and North Vietnamese are a plague. We have to eliminate them. They have no regard for human life.” From Malcolm X: “Don’t change the white man’s mind. You can’t change his mind, and that whole thing about appealing to the moral conscience of America – America’s conscience is bankrupt.” From the conflict in Israel and Palestine: “Arabs don't understand anything but force. So, it makes all the sense in the world to show them that we aren't afraid to use brute force against them. Only when we do this, will the world respect us, and America follow in our example.” From the tension with North Korea: “These barbarians in the east don't understand anything but FORCE.” From Osama Bin Laden: “Bush and Blair don't understand anything but the power of force. Every time they kill us, we kill them, so the balance of terror can be achieved.” From the Iraq war: “We may need to flatten Fallujah. We may need to destroy it. We may need to grind it, pulverize it and salt the soil, as the Romans did with troublesome enemies.” Also from the Iraq war: “The U.S. should blitzkrieg them with so much force that they realize that their cause is futile. For every one of ours that dies in a terrorist attack, we should kill a hundred of them, without worrying whether the dead were terrorists or innocent bystanders. You can't reason with these people; they don't understand anything but force.” From Donald Rumsfeld: “This is not an enemy that can be ignored, or negotiated with, or appeased.” That is, wiping them out is our only option.
Are all of those voices right? Are any of them? Are those whom we claim as the great moral leaders of human history totally inadequate to meeting the reality of terrorism? Far from it; on the contrary, many of them arose in situations akin to terrorism. Jesus, living under an often-brutal Roman occupation, surrounded by those who screamed for revolt, could still say, “I say to you, love your enemies, pray for those who persecute you, that you may be children of your heavenly Father, for he makes his sun rise on the bad and the good, and causes rain to fall on the just and the unjust. For is you love those who love you, what recompense will you have? Do not the tax collectors do the same? And if you greet your brothers only, what is unusual about that? Do not the pagans do the same?” Mohandas Gandhi, no stranger to the brutalization of his people, could still say, “Hatred can be overcome only by love. Counter-hatred only increases the surface as well as the depth of hatred.” Those who would dismiss such sentiments as pious and unrealistic should consider at once the deep-seated violence and racism he faced and the unparalleled measure of the success such pious sentiments achieved.
After white racists bombed a church in Birmingham, killing four adolescent girls, Martin Luther King preached their eulogy, including the following lines (which lost him many supporters for not calling for violence against whites, who had seemingly proved that they didn’t understand anything but force): “We must not become bitter; nor must we harbor the desire to retaliate with violence. We must not lose faith in our white brothers. Somehow we must believe that the most misguided among them can learn to respect the dignity and worth of all human personality.” That is, although it is hard at this moment to see the possibility of conversion in those who would do this, hope is our only means of warding off the despair that would demand that, for the sake of our innocents, we must crush those who would crush us. Similarly he could say, “To our most bitter opponents we say: ‘We shall match your capacity to inflict suffering by our capacity to endure suffering. We shall meet your physical force with soul force. Do to us what you will, and we shall continue to love you…Throw us in jail, and we shall still love you. Bomb our homes and threaten our children, and we shall still love you. Send your hooded perpetrators of violence into our community at the midnight hour and beat us and leave us half dead, and we shall still love you. But be ye assured that we will wear you down by our capacity to suffer. One day we shall win freedom, but not only for ourselves. We shall so appeal to your heart and conscience that we shall win you in the process, and our victory will be a double victory.’” Wouldn’t he have been justified in calling for vengeance? Don’t people have the right to defend themselves? Yes, but… But would that kind of backlash made them safer, would it have ended violence against blacks, would it have enabled even the very mixed record on race relations that this country currently has?
This is of enormous significance; each of them could have believed, easily and with justification, that they were up against enemies who understood nothing but force, but had they done so, history would have progressed very differently than it has. Before we repeat to ourselves that hope is not what we need now, or that the group at hand is beyond hope, that they are monsters who truly understand nothing but force, perhaps we can ask what it would mean to have the kind of Christian hope that makes possible the transformation of the enemy (and ourselves) through accepting suffering as opposed to inflicting it.
Tuesday, February 13, 2007
Sleet and the Rhinoceros
Maybe it's just that I've been reading a ton of Thomas Merton lately, but last night, making the 15-minute walk to my car, the (relative) quiet and the (relative) dark made me think to the opening of his "Rain and the Rhinoceros." Almost no one around at midnight on a Monday, with just enough cold to make me pay attention, but not so bitter as to be miserable. Keeping my head down because of the rain, it all came together to enable an almost monastic quieting; without the usual hustle of things to look around at on campus, a purposely reduced influx of information was possible. The little bit of wind felt clean, like it was clearing out some great inscape, making a space big enough for the quiet to surround me. How much more must it have meant in the woods of Kentucky 42 years ago, miles from the hum of machinery and the glare of light pollution, "all that speech pouring down, selling nothing, judging nobody, drenching the thick mulch of dead leaves, soaking the trees, filling the gullies and crannies of the wood with water."
I came in early to the office today, to meet with a student who is considering taking part in an act of civil disobedience against the war, and I found myself sifting through threads of admiration and a little guilt (or ego-bruising) and peace with the means I have to respond to the war where I am, in the class I am taking (Ethics and War), in what I am writing, in my work with the students in my care. If a possibility of civil disobedience in which I believe comes my way, I am open to taking part, but something tells me that to go looking for it would be about my ego instead of taking a stance on something that I think is worth putting myself on the line for.
mercy within mercy within mercy...
I came in early to the office today, to meet with a student who is considering taking part in an act of civil disobedience against the war, and I found myself sifting through threads of admiration and a little guilt (or ego-bruising) and peace with the means I have to respond to the war where I am, in the class I am taking (Ethics and War), in what I am writing, in my work with the students in my care. If a possibility of civil disobedience in which I believe comes my way, I am open to taking part, but something tells me that to go looking for it would be about my ego instead of taking a stance on something that I think is worth putting myself on the line for.
mercy within mercy within mercy...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)